 |
 |
 |

 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
USIP: AMERICA'S STRATEGIC BLUNDER IN GEORGIA AND THE DEATH OF THE ROSE REVOLUTION

What began on August 7 as a reckless act of aggression by Georgia to bludgeon the separatist province of South Ossetia into submission, quickly escalated to Russian military intervention in Georgia, and the conflict's transformation into a proxy war between the U.S. and Moscow. What's at stake in this conflict is not Georgia's sovereignty or that of its breakaway provinces of South Ossetia and Abkhazi, but NATO's eastward expansion to Russia's borders. The short-hot war in Georgia was Russia's red line in the sand signaling to the U.S., Western Europe and its former Soviet republics that the strategic military encirclement of Russia stops here
The Bush Administration, aided by a complicit Democratic Party Congress made a monumental strategic error in pushing NATO membership for Georgia at the last alliance summit. Coming on the heals of American sponsorship of Kosovo's independence, Bush's action could only be seen as a provocation. That Bush blatantly antagonized Moscow with no intention of defending Georgia if attacked by Russia constituted the height of irresponsibility. The U.S. financed, armed and trained the Georgian army, led by the political neophyte President Saakashvili. Yet despite explicit warnings from Bush and Sec. of State Rice that Georgia not attack its separatist provinces, Saskshvili couldn't restrain his propensity for committing atrocities against South Ossetia-thus provoking Russia to arms.
Had France and Germany not resisted Bush's imprimatur for Georgian inclusion in NATO, the U.S. and Western Europe would at this moment be legally obliged to attack Russian forces in Georgia. Coming at a time when the 26 nation NATO Alliance can't ante up enough troops to defeat the resurgent Taliban in Afghanistan, NATO would have undoubtedly split over an armed intervention to confront Russia on Georgian soil. Once again, this comedy of errors so typical of the Bush administration's reckless foreign policy has undermined U.S.-European Union relations and pushed U.S. - Russian relations to a breaking point.
For all President Bush's rhetoric about punishing the Russians, little if anything will be done in his last five months in office. The U.S. still needs Russia as a partner to check Iran's nuclear program, police loose nukes and proliferation, not to mention assisting the West in the "war on terror." For its part, Russia has long since left the West, and while it may cooperate in these areas based on its own national interest, Russia increasingly regards the U.S. as a hostile adversary and will act accordingly.
Going forward Moscow's political and military posture will become much more aggressive in what it calls its "Near Abroad." Russia's harsh warnings to Poland for accepting U.S. missile interceptors and the Ukraine over naval access agreements to Black Sea ports are illustrative of growing tensions between Moscow and the West. Russia will also attempt to accelerate its growing anti-U.S. energy alliance with China in Central Asia and the Caspian Sea basin to push back U.S. moves to consolidate access to energy resources.
While the media speculates about the resumption of the Cold War between the U.S. and Russia, the larger issue at hand is the growing potential for a new geo-political divide whose footprint is slowly but surely being called into existence; A new East-West energy divide that begins in the Middle East with Syria, Iraq and Iran and sweeps eastward through Russia and China, with an ambivalent India wedged in the middle. In the 21st Century "Great Game" in Central Asia, three countries share the majority of the region's energy resources, namely Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan and Turkmenistan.
The essence of U.S-Russian geo-political contention in Central Asia is twofold: first, control of production of the oil and gas, and second, control of the pipelines which will transfer the oil to the Western markets. It is not insignificant in the grand scheme of the conflict in Georgia that three oil pipelines run through Georgia to the West, all circumventing Russia.
Ultimately, the Georgian crisis will be resolved in the short-run with face saving measures that mollify all sides. Russians troops will remain in South Ossetia and Abkhazia at pre-crisis levels as outlined in the French brokered cease fire agreement. Both provinces will formally remain autonomous regions of Georgia, although Moscow will exert greater political, economic and military leverage. Georgia's prospects of gaining entry into NATO are all but dead in the foreseeable future. The fragrant blooms of Georgia's Rose Revolution have fallen, leaving only the painful thorns of a divided and war-torn country trapped between the imperial ambitions of Moscow and the West.
Webster BROOKS, Editor of the U.S. Iran Peace Project website
U.S. - Iran Peace Project, August 18, 2008
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |

Other materials on this topic
Hot topics
Digest
07.04.2008
|
RFE/RL: U.S./RUSSIA: FRIENDLY WORDS, BUT BUSH AND PUTIN FAIL TO RESOLVE DISPUTES
|
Setting aside growing tension on a number of issues, Putin and Bush appeared eager to end their presidential relationship on a high note.
|
03.04.2008
|
RFE/RL: NATO WELCOMES CROATIA, ALBANIA, BUT ASKS UKRAINE, GEORGIA, MACEDONIA TO WAIT
|
Speaking today at NATO's summit in Bucharest, Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer said the alliance wants to welcome Ukraine and Georgia as members someday.
|
25.12.2007
|
THE GEORGIAN TIMES: WITH OR WITHOUT RUSSIA?
|
The foreign policy priorities of the presidential candidates. Most put Euro-Atlantic and NATO integration front and center, but good relations with Russia is, for some, another major consideration.
|
12.10.2007
|
RFE/RL: EU MAKING ITS VOICE HEARD IN MOSCOW'S BACKYARD
|
What Europe does want to do is to support democratic reforms in former Soviet states like Georgia and Ukraine, and push for change in autocracies like Belarus.
|
09.10.2007
|
RFE/RL: FRANCE'S SARKOZY TAKES CRITICAL STAND ON FIRST TRIP TO MOSCOW
|
Far from offering the warm embrace shown Moscow by his predecessor, Jacques Chirac, the 52-year-old Sarkozy has been nothing short of blunt in expressing his views on Russia.
|
17.07.2007
|
CAUCAZ.COM: “THE PRESENT SITUATION CONCERNING THE SOUTH CAUCASUS CONFLICTS CANNOT GO ON FOREVER, THERE MUST BE SOME MOVEMENT.”
|
Interview with Ambassador Per Eklund, Head of Delegation of the European Commission to Georgia and Armenia.
|
|
Expert forum
SUMMING UP THE UN SECURITY COUNCIL MEETING ON GEORGIA
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
25.07.2008
|
I believe that the withdrawal of the Russian railroad troops from Abkhazia and the UN Security Council meeting, which was held on July 21 at Georgia’s request, cannot be directly linked to each other.
|
DETERIORATION OF THE RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS
|
ALEXANDER RONDELI
|
23.07.2008
|
I do not think there is a relation between the UN Security Council meeting where the Russian fighter jets’ violations of the Georgian airspace were discussed and the withdrawal of the Russian railroad troops from Abkhazia.
|
“SEA BREEZE-2008” AND PROSPECTS OF UKRAINE’S JOINING NATO
|
VITALY PORTNIKOV
|
22.07.2008
|
The holding of “Sea Breeze” military exercises and Ukraine’s joining NATO should be regarded as two different processes. Some people want to unite them, but Kyiv has not applied for the NATO membership yet. Ukraine has not received the NATO Membership Action Plan and, apparently, will not recieve it in December.
|
SITUATION IN ABKHAZIA
|
SERGEI BAGAPSH
|
22.05.2008
|
What will Abkhazia do, if Georgia joins NATO? Abkhazia will do nothing. Let Georgia join NATO even tomorrow. We do not care about that.
|
“RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS CAN BECOME MUCH BETTER”
|
EROSI KITSMARISHVILI
|
21.05.2008
|
Currently, there are several negative points in the Russian-Georgian relations. The first one is Georgia’s bid for the NATO membership, the second one is Tbilisi’s conflict with the breakaway territories – Abkhazia and South Ossetia. There are also the problems of the bilateral relations.
|
THE RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
25.04.2008
|
Almost all significant political forces in Georgia, including the ruling party, say that there are sufficient reasons for making the compromises with Russia that would not infringe upon Georgia’s national interests.
|
DOES NATO ENLARGEMENT POSE A THREAT TO RUSSIA?
|
KONSTANTIN ZATULIN, ALEXANDER KONOVALOV, TATYANA PARKHALINA, OLES DONIY, LEONID KOZHARA, IVAN ZAETS, ANDREW KUCHINS
|
07.04.2008
|
"Why do the Central and Eastern European countries seek to join NATO? For many of them it is a way to join the EU. Many countries took this as institutionalization of independence from Moscow. For many countries it was a way to return to Europe," Tatyana Parkhalina.
|
NATO, THE CIS AND RUSSIA AFTER BUCHAREST
|
STEPHEN BLANK
|
02.04.2008
|
In advance of NATO’s Bucharest summit Russia has decided to employ the traditional Soviet tactics of intimidation and blackmail to block NATO’s enlargement.
|
WILL THE POST-SOVIET BREAKAWAY REGIONS BE RECOGNIZED?
|
DMITRY MEDOEV, GURAM GUMBA, SERGEI ARUTYUNOV, SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
19.03.2008
|
"If to look at a map, one can realize that in the event of the conflict in Abkhazia the Georgian party is doomed to defeat, as has happened before. This is why Abkhazia has a very good chance of becoming independent," Sergei Arutyunov.
|
NEW BIG GAME IN CENTRAL ASIA
|
ANDREY GROZIN
|
14.11.2007
|
At present the West has better attitude towards Turkmenistan than it did under former President Saparmurat Niyazov, although since he died, the regime has hardly changed. This shows once more that oil and gas are more important than democracy.
|
FRENCH-RUSSIAN RELATIONS
|
ALEKSANDR RAHR
|
12.10.2007
|
The economic interests prompt Nicolas Sarkozy to get to the Russian market. The French big business and, first and foremost, state corporations urge the President to do so.
|
SOUTH OSSETIA STATUS: LOOKING FOR A NEW APPROACH
|
GHIA NODIA
|
26.07.2007
|
On July 24 Tbilisi hosted the first meeting of the State Committee on the status of South Ossetia. The Committee is intended to work out an approach to resolving the argument about South Ossetia’s status that would be acceptable both to Georgia and South Ossetia.
|
SOUTH OSSETIA’S CLONED SEPARATISM
|
OLEG FESENKO, VITALY KULIK
|
13.06.2007
|
Early in May the Tbilisi officials voiced that “it is necessary to carry on the political dialogue with the authorities of the Tskhinvali region”. But Mikheil Saakashvili’s government decided to negotiate with the “alternative President” of South Ossetia Dmitry Sanakoev, who is close to the Georgian government.
|
RESULTS OF THE RUSSIA – EU SUMMIT
|
ALEKSANDR RAHR
|
22.05.2007
|
As to the influence of the new French President upon the EU policy towards Russia, from now on Russia will have to consider the EU's opinion.
|
GEORGIA – NATO: PROSPECTS FOR COOPERATION
|
MERAB PACHULIA
|
09.03.2007
|
Ambitions of the Georgian authorities to develop cooperation with NATO are largely supported by the population. There is a consensus on the benefits that the country could receive after acquiring membership of the Alliance, though contradictions remain.
|
GEORGIA’S WAY TO NATO STREAMLINED
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
19.02.2007
|
Members of the “National Forum” and some other opposition parties fear that Georgia may join NATO without Abkhazia and South Ossetia, thus losing those territories for good.
|
GEORGIA’S PROSPECTS ON ITS WITHDRAWAL FROM THE CIS
|
VLADIMIR ZHARIKHIN
|
04.05.2006
|
The economic preferences, which some of the CIS countries have due to the Russian authorities’ decision, such as gas delivery at a cut price, etc. have nothing to do with the CIS Charter. It is a matter of the bilateral relations.
|
RUSSIAN – EU RELATIONS
|
THIERRY DE MONTBRIAL
|
12.09.2005
|
Thierry de Montbrial, director of the French Institute of International Relations, is perhaps the best French expert on Russia and far from the last one in Europe. A talk with him enables one to get a clear idea of the current situation in Europe, which is being torn by disputes over its borders, asking the question, who, why and for what reason can be considered a European?
|
ABKHAZIA: NEW EASTERN POLICY
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
29.07.2005
|
The Georgian minister on conflict settlement, Giorgi Khaindrava, called the recent meeting between the leaders of Abkhazia and South Ossetia a "statehood game." While Georgian officials continue to describe political developments in the breakaway republics in this way, Abkhazia is taking a number of very important political steps that may give its cause a boost.
|
RUSSIA - EU RELATIONS
|
FYODOR LUKYANOV
|
04.07.2005
|
The Russian government’s refusal to invite the Presidents of Poland and Lithuania to celebrate a 750-year anniversary of Kaliningrad can be interpreted as Russia’s desire to show the new Europe that it has more important and influential friends in the EU. The leaders of Germany and France Gerhard Schroeder and Jacques Chirac were invited to the celebrations of Kaliningrad's 750th anniversary.
|
RUSSIA AND THE CAUCASUS REGION
|
ANATOLY BELIAYEV
|
22.06.2005
|
Predictably, BP Azerbaijan has said that it does not want to export oil produced in the Azerbaijani sector of the Caspian Sea via the Baku-Novorossiisk pipeline. This means that Russia, which is already losing its influence on the Caucasus, will suffer serious economic losses.
|
RUSSIAN - GEORGIAN RELATIONS
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
19.06.2005
|
Russia's relations with Georgia are one of the most cute and problematic aspects of foreign policy in the Caucasus. Previously "fraternal," i.e. former Soviet republic, Georgia has become one of Moscow's most intractable partners in the former Soviet space.
|
RUSSIA AND THE CAUCASUS REGION
|
VYACHESLAV IGRUNOV
|
17.06.2005
|
The agreements on the closure of Russian bases in Georgia, which were reached after dramatic negotiations and moves, have cast a fresh light on Russia's role and future in the Caucasus.
|
CAUCASUS IN THE GEOPOLITICAL CONTEXT
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
28.05.2005
|
The Russian military presence in Georgia has become the key issue of the Caucasian Big Game in the last few months. Discussions of the timeframe and speed of their withdrawal from Georgia overshadowed the problems of Abkhazia and South Ossetia.
|
CENTRAL ASIA IN THE GEOPOLITICAL CONTEXT
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
28.05.2005
|
Many people in Russia see America's presence in the post-Soviet (Eurasian) area as virtually an attempt to end Russia's national sovereignty. Alexander Dugin, a prominent theoretician of Russian traditionalism, recently said the United States was trying to penetrate the "canonical territory" of Russian diplomacy. However, the military-political presence of the world's No.1 superpower in some ex-Soviet republics might become an important stabilizing factor.
|
Analysis
|
Opinion
BAD HABITS ARE CONTAGIOUS
|
Boris Kagarlitsky |
14.08.2008
|
Georgia has resolutely condemned Russia’s actions in Chechnya. Russia has severely criticized NATO actions towards Serbia. Later on the Georgian authorities tried to do the same thing in South Ossetia as the Russian authorities had done in Chechnya. Moscow decided to treat Georgia in the same way as NATO had treated Serbia.
|
VICIOUS CIRCLE
|
Boris Kagarlitsky |
17.07.2008
|
The Russian foreign policy boringly runs around in circles: the row with Estonia on the historic past, the squabbles between Moscow and Kyiv over the Crimea and Russia’s Black Sea Fleet, the confrontation with Georgia because of its breakaway republics etc. After having made a full circle we are back to square one - another conflict with Georgia.
|
NATO EXPANSION – DON’T EXPECT THE RUSSIANS TO AGREE
|
John Marone |
18.06.2008
|
If NATO can bring Ukrainians rule of law and a decent living standard, it would already have justified its expansion. But judging by the way other Western reforms have been perverted in Ukraine, one couldn’t be blamed for having serious doubts. Probably with more candidness, Mr. Yushchenko pointed out that Ukraine can join any international organization that it likes.
|
GEORGIA COULD BE OBSTREPEROUS OVER RUSSIA’S WTO BID
|
Jules Evans |
20.11.2006
|
The Georgian government has apparently been offering olive branches to the Russian government over the last two weeks, with the demotion of hawkish defence minister Irakli Okruashvili to the ministry of economy (he’s since resigned).
|
|
|
 |
 |
|