Main page                           
Eurasian Home - analytical resource


OIL CONFLICT BETWEEN MINSK AND MOSCOW MAY MAKE BELARUS’S POLITICAL SYSTEM COLLAPSE

Print version

SERGEY NIKOLYUK,
Political analyst, Minsk

The customs duty on the Russian oil for Minsk is the issue of the Belarusian regime’s survival. That’s why Minsk reacts so sharply to Moscow’s unwillingness to supply over 5 million tons of oil without charging the duty.

What surprised me most of all is that Aliaksandr Lukashenka gave the Belarusian people various social promises at the end of 2009. I’ve analyzed the recent public opinion polls, and I can say that the society hasn’t put pressure on the Belarusian authorities concerning the social issues. But Aliaksandr Lukashenka reminded the people of his promises, that their average monthly income should be $500. He spoke about that as long ago as 2006.

Mr. Lukashenka’s mentioning this figure means that it is sacred, so all the plans and other figures were adjusted to $500. Therefore, the GDP annual growth was expected to make up 11-13%. This is during the global financial crisis!

Why did this happen? I believe that the authorities are not adequate any more. Aliaksandr Lukashenka has always said that he took a realistic view of things. As Mr. Lukashenka has been Belarus’ President for 16 years and there have not been strong figures in his entourage, he ceased to be a realist. No government officials objected to the figures’ being adjusted to $500.

Now it appears that if Russia does not grant Belarus preferences, those plans will fall to the ground. How can this problem be solved? This is not the first conflict between Moscow and Minsk. Till now, as a result of the conflicts, Belarus’ demands have been almost fulfilled.

Russia is still a traditional empire rather than a colonial one, which is a kind of a business project. A traditional empire is based on the idea of disseminating the Orthodoxy or the Communism. And an idea should be paid for. Unlike a colonial empire, in a traditional empire the resources go from the center to the provinces. So it is not fortuitous that Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, while meeting Belarusian journalists in 2009, said that the Russian preferences as the reduced prices for source of raw materials cost $50 billion.

It is not clear whether Moscow will make a compromise again. Russia laid down tough conditions, so it is not known how make Russia compromise here.

As regards the Belarusian government’s reaction, so far Aliaksandr Lukashenka does not make strongly-worded statements. But everything can occur. Now an oil conflict with Moscow may make Belarus’ political system collapse.

January 14, 2010




Our readers’ comments



There are no comments on this article.

You will be the first.

Send a comment

Other materials on this topic
Hot topics
Digest

03.12.2009

EURASIANET.ORG: RUSSIA: MOSCOW EMBRACES NEW INITIATIVE TO FORGE POST-SOVIET TRADE BLOC

Russia wants to turn a newly minted Customs Union with Belarus and Kazakhstan into its major vehicle for post-Soviet economic integration in Central Eurasia.


Expert forum
“THE CUSTOMS UNION MAY BE THE LAST EFFORT OF RUSSIA TO KEEP THE CIS COUNTRIES TOGETHER”

YAROSLAV ROMANCHUK

02.12.2009

The documents establishing the Customs Union of Belarus, Kazakhstan and Russia were signed on November 27, 2009 in Minsk by Aliaksandr Lukashenka, Nursultan Nazarbayev and Dmitry Medvedev.


RUSSIA HAS SUPPORTED THE BELARUSIAN ECONOMY AND WILL DO THAT

SERGEY NIKOLYUK

25.06.2009

Moscow has no other ways to maintain relations with Minsk but to support Aliaksandr Lukashenka’s regime. Despite the conflicts, neither side will raise the question of Belarus-Russia Union project termination. I believe the current leaders would not like to go down in history as destroyers of the Belarus-Russia Union.


HOW BELARUSIANS ASSESS CONFLICT WITH RUSSIA

YAROSLAV ROMANCHUK

23.06.2009

According to the public opinion polls, 90% of the Belarusians have considered Russia a friendly state. At present this figure can fall to 70%, this is the maximum, to which the national mass media criticism can lead.


“BELARUS’ POLICY OF BALANCING BETWEEN EUROPE AND RUSSIA IS SUCCESSFUL”

VALERY KARBALEVICH

06.03.2009

Europe concluded that its previous tactics (democratization demand, sanctions toward Belarus’ authorities, support for the opposition) were inefficient. Poland and Lithuania urged the EU to change its policy towards Minsk. Germany is also interested in development of economic relations with Belarus.


WHY RUSSIA CREDITS ITS NEIGHBORING COUNTRIES

YURI PANASIK

19.02.2009

The world financial crisis is a real challenge not only for Russia but also for the regional integration organizations and bilateral alliances in the former Soviet Union where Russia pretends to be the leader. This offers new opportunities as well as new challenges to Russia.



Analysis

22.06.2009

BELARUS EXTERNAL DEBT: SUSTAINING LEVELS IN A TIME OF GLOBAL CRISIS

Eurasian Home with a kind permission of The Pontis Foundation and The Belarusian Institute for Strategic Studies publishes a paper, prepared by Gleb Shymanovich, "Belarus external debt: Sustaining Levels in a Time of Global Crisis". The paper takes a close look at how Belarus´ foreign debt is structured and what potential impact it could have on the Belarusian economy in the upcoming period.


19.06.2009

WHAT EASTERN PARTNERSHIP SHOULD BRING TO BELARUS

Eurasian Home with a kind permission of The Belarusian Institute for Strategic Studies (BISS) publishes a study “What Eastern Partnership should bring to Belarus”, in which BISS analyzes possibilities of the Eastern Partnership initiative and its potential to transform Belarusian political regime.


17.02.2009

BELARUS: SHAPING THE SPACE FOR CHANGE

Eurasian Home with a kind permission of The Belarusian Institute for Strategic Studies (BISS) publishes the analytical report “Belarus: Shaping the Space for Change”, which reflects directions of panel discussions as well as conclusions made on their basis during the second annual international conference carried out in Kyiv, Ukraine, on 11-12 November 2008.



Opinion
A PREPARATORY YEAR
Aleh Novikau

26.01.2010

While Russian and Belarusian officials were carrying on negotiations on the Russian oil prices, on which 50% of Belarus’ annual GDP depends, Minsk hosted the big hockey holiday. The local team of veterans with its unchallenged captain, Aliaksandr Lukashenka, played in a tournament to win the Belarusian President’s prize. Simultaneously, during the ceremony of granting awards to cultural workers, Aliaksandr Lukashenka delivered a long speech.



Author’s opinion on other topics

RUSSIA HAS SUPPORTED THE BELARUSIAN ECONOMY AND WILL DO THAT

25 June 2009

Moscow has no other ways to maintain relations with Minsk but to support Aliaksandr Lukashenka’s regime. Despite the conflicts, neither side will raise the question of Belarus-Russia Union project termination. I believe the current leaders would not like to go down in history as destroyers of the Belarus-Russia Union.


BELARUS IS TAKING THE ROAD OF LIBERALIZATION

06 March 2009

Minsk’s probable participation in the EU’s foreign-policy program “Eastern Partnership” is evidence of serious changes in Belarus. Rapprochement between Brussels and Minsk and, in general, of Belarus and the West is connected with the liberalization processes in Belarus, first and foremost, in the economic sphere.


THE OUTCOME OF THE PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS IN BELARUS

30 September 2008

There is no sense in attaching superfluous importance to the last election campaign in Belarus. Previous Parliament drafted only one bill on its own for four years. All its activities were reduced to the acceptance of the Cabinet and President’s initiatives.

 events
 news
 opinion
 expert forum
 digest
 hot topics
 analysis
 databases
 about us
 the Eurasia Heritage Foundation projects
 links
 our authors
Eurasia Heritage Foundation