Main page                           
Eurasian Home - analytical resource



BORIS  KAGARLITSKY, MOSCOW
HOW TO QUARREL WITH A NEIGHBOUR

Print version               


It seems that after the conflict with Georgia all we need is to clash with Ukraine. A lot of politicians both in Russia and Ukraine would definitely like it to happen.

The public statements made by Moscow Mayor Yury Luzhkov, whom the status of the Ukrainian city of Sevastopol gives no rest at all, are unlikely to surprise or really offend anybody – everyone has already got accustomed to such declarations. And the problem of the distant year 2017, when there will be a need to relocate the Russian Black Sea Fleet from the Crimea, is not yet on the agenda: most probably, new politicians will have come to power in both Moscow and Kyiv by that time.

But a Caucasian crisis resulted in a new quarrel over Sevastopol, this time provoked by the Ukrainian side.

From now on, the Black Sea Fleet ships or Russian fighter jets’ leaving their bases in Sevastopol should meet some provocative requirements, established by the Ukrainian authorities. Seventy two hours before the departure the Command are obliged not only to notify the Ukrainian authorities of vessels’ leaving the base, but also to let them know of the purposes and route of their movement and to report on the arms and ammunition on board. This requirement does not accord with the secrecy that is always observed in the army, particularly considering that Ukraine maintains close relations with both NATO and Georgia. Moreover, the new requirements, which have been laid down by Kyiv, are at odds with the existing treaties on the status of the Russian Black Sea Fleet and Sevastopol.

It is easy to guess that sooner or later a Russian ship will not obey those requirements and the Ukrainian party will use force to block its leaving the base. Here is classical casus belli.

On the other hand, the Slavic way of doing work will almost certainly destroy all the crafty designs of the warmongers. At worst, the Russians will pretend to report, and the Ukrainians will pretend to believe those reports. After all, a ship can go to the Russian city of Novorossiysk and at sea it can receive the order to head for the Abkhazian city of Sukhumi or the Georgian city of Poti.

But it is alarming that the tireless politicians in Kyiv and Moscow are thinking of more and more outright and sophisticated ways of provoking clashes between Russia and Ukraine. Now there are rumours that armed conflicts could take place. The Russian media write openly and cynically that after the ‘peacemaking operation’ in Georgia the ‘friendship-making operation’ should be held in Ukraine.

The current Russian-Ukrainian conflict refutes the statement that close economic relations hinder confrontation. As an oil exporter, Russia depends on the Ukrainian transit routes, and Ukraine, which is an industrial country with limited resources, needs Russian raw materials and fuel urgently. However, this interdependence leads to constant quarrels rather than to general concord, cooperation and mutual understanding. It comes natural as each party seeks to benefit from this partnership as much as possible and makes the least concessions to each other. The logic of capitalism turns economic cooperation into a kind of confrontation.

And yet, if the Russian-Ukrainian conflicts had nothing to do with much more important causes for instability, they would be rather comical. Even the collision between Moscow and the West over the Georgian events, which was unimaginable five or seven years ago, shows not only the deterioration of the relations between the parties involved in the Caucasian politics, but also more and more strained international relations, which is an integral part of all the large-scale economic depressions.

It is clear as daylight that things in Ukraine and Russia will go from bad to worse in the near future. Therefore, the “external enemy” will be looked for by the authorities in both countries more intensely. What’s most terrible is that the politicians become hostages of their own rhetoric. If the politicians speak about their irreconcilability for a long time, they will have to act in accordance with their words and to start fighting sooner or later. The politicians are concerned about their popularity ratings, but do not care about public opinions. They are ready to take risky steps in order to save their faces, but they do not ask the citizens about their vision of the political future. In other words, the ordinary people are unable to influence the politicians and to stave off confrontation.

There is nothing else left to do but hope either that the officials are cautious and have common sense or that the political crisis will make them address the internal problems before their creating external ones.

Boris Kagarlitsky is Director of the Institute of Globalization and Social Movements

September 11, 2008



Our readers’ comments



There are no comments on this article.

You will be the first.

Send a comment

Other materials on this topic
Hot topics
Digest

12.05.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: PRESIDENT IN DEEP WATER?

Yushchenko is not ready to agree to an honorable post of parliamentary president yet. Tymoshenko showed her readiness to prolong his term as president without any elections under the condition of substantial reduction of his authority.

15.04.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: NATO STRENGTHENS UKRAINE AND ITSELF

"NATO has always taken Russia into account when considering the modalities of enlargement, the timing of it and the likely consequences of it. But it has never granted Russia a veto over this process or a role to play in it," James Sherr. 

14.04.2008

RFE/RL: NATO: KYIV, TBILISI FACE MORE OBSTACLES THAN SIMPLY RUSSIAN RESISTANCE

Days before the NATO summit in Bucharest began, Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili rolled out a new peace initiative for breakaway Abkhazia.

03.04.2008

RFE/RL: NATO WELCOMES CROATIA, ALBANIA, BUT ASKS UKRAINE, GEORGIA, MACEDONIA TO WAIT

Speaking today at NATO's summit in Bucharest, Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer said the alliance wants to welcome Ukraine and Georgia as members someday.

01.11.2007

RFE/RL: GEORGIA SEEKS END TO RUSSIAN PEACEKEEPERS’ MANDATE IN ABKHAZIA

Georgia says it will move to formally ask Russian peacekeepers to leave the breakaway region of Abkhazia following reports that they seized and beat five Georgian police officers.


Expert forum
RIVALRY BETWEEN THE USA AND RUSSIA FOR THE POST-SOVIET SPACE

VIKTOR KREMENIUK

04.09.2008

The Caucasian conflict indicates intense rivalry between the USA and Russia for the post-Soviet space. Russia still hopes to put an end to the expansion of the U.S. influence.


THE OUTCOME OF THE EXTRAORDINARY EU SUMMIT ON SOUTH OSSETIAN CONFLICT

VLADIMIR CHIZHOV

03.09.2008

The outcome of the extraordinary EU summit held on September 1 in Brussels was more or less predictable, both in terms of the views expressed by the EU member states and in terms of the EU Presidency conclusion.


THE OUTBREAK OF VIOLATION IN SOUTH OSSETIA IS AT ODDS WITH THE INTERESTS OF ALL THE PARTIES

ANDREY MAKARYCHEV

20.08.2008

South Ossetia and Georgia have been at war with each other since last week. The towns and cities came under fire, the reservists were mobilized. There are the killed and the wounded, and a lot of refugees.


CELEBRATION OF THE 1,020 ANNIVERSARY OF THE ACCEPTANCE OF CHRISTIANITY BY KYIVAN RUS

VADIM KARASYOV

04.08.2008

We should not discuss the theology issues and the relations within the Orthodox Church. We should discuss the celebration of the 1,020th anniversary of the acceptance of Christianity by Rus where there was a complicated political intrigue.


“SEA BREEZE-2008” AND PROSPECTS OF UKRAINE’S JOINING NATO

VITALY PORTNIKOV

22.07.2008

The holding of “Sea Breeze” military exercises and Ukraine’s joining NATO should be regarded as two different processes. Some people want to unite them, but Kyiv has not applied for the NATO membership yet. Ukraine has not received the NATO Membership Action Plan and, apparently, will not recieve it in December.


“RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS CAN BECOME MUCH BETTER”

EROSI KITSMARISHVILI

21.05.2008

Currently, there are several negative points in the Russian-Georgian relations. The first one is Georgia’s bid for the NATO membership, the second one is Tbilisi’s conflict with the breakaway territories – Abkhazia and South Ossetia. There are also the problems of the bilateral relations.


DOES NATO ENLARGEMENT POSE A THREAT TO RUSSIA?

KONSTANTIN ZATULIN, ALEXANDER KONOVALOV, TATYANA PARKHALINA, OLES DONIY, LEONID KOZHARA, IVAN ZAETS, ANDREW KUCHINS

07.04.2008

"Why do the Central and Eastern European countries seek to join NATO? For many of them it is a way to join the EU. Many countries took this as institutionalization of independence from Moscow. For many countries it was a way to return to Europe," Tatyana Parkhalina.


NATO, THE CIS AND RUSSIA AFTER BUCHAREST

STEPHEN BLANK

02.04.2008

In advance of NATO’s Bucharest summit Russia has decided to employ the traditional Soviet tactics of intimidation and blackmail to block NATO’s enlargement.


NATO-RUSSIA BREAK: A SIGNIFICANT POSSIBILITY

GEORGETA POURCHOT

01.04.2008

The Bucharest NATO summit offers a significant possibility that NATO’s and Russia’s positions on a variety of issues will further diverge, marking the beginning of the end of this uneven relationship.


VISIT OF UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT VIKTOR YUSHCHENKO TO MOSCOW

DMITRY VYDRIN

14.02.2008

Moscow is afraid of making Yuliya Tymoshenko a counterpart in talks on the gas relations. As a result, Viktor Yushchenko again became the major negotiator with Russia. 



Opinion
UKRAINE’S INDEFENSIBLE POSITION - IN THE WAKE OF GEORGIA
John Marone

01.09.2008

Since 1991, Ukraine has sat on the fence like a country coquette with her back to her jealous ex-husband Russia, from which the country’s ‘elite’ have nevertheless continued to get rich on cheap gas, while batting her eyes at the glamorous West, which offers lots of nice gifts but never a firm proposal of marriage.


ENOUGH GRAND-STANDING BY THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT
Jules Evans

27.08.2008

The typical criticism of the UK’s Foreign Office is the one eloquently expressed in John Le Carre’s The Constant Gardener - that they are pitiless practitioners of real-politik who care more about stability than idealism, and who only really work to protect the interests of British corporations, rather than British values. But on Russia, the Foreign Office seems to have erred on the other side.


BAD HABITS ARE CONTAGIOUS
Boris Kagarlitsky

14.08.2008

Georgia has resolutely condemned Russia’s actions in Chechnya. Russia has severely criticized NATO actions towards Serbia. Later on the Georgian authorities tried to do the same thing in South Ossetia as the Russian authorities had done in Chechnya. Moscow decided to treat Georgia in the same way as NATO had treated Serbia.


WADING INTO THE WOES – UKRAINIAN POLITICIANS SHOW HOW MUCH THEY CARE
John Marone

06.08.2008

Ukraine has again been challenged by disaster – not another coalmine disaster, which continue to claim lives on a small scale, or a deadly military mishap (thank goodness), or even a gas explosion at one of the country’s innumerable apartment blocs. No, this time it’s flooding in the country’s rural western regions.


RELIGION IN UKRAINE - THERE'S NOTHING UNIFYING ABOUT IT
John Marone

28.07.2008

On Friday, July 25, the Russian Foreign Ministry released a statement in which it noted that "events dedicated to the 1,020th anniversary of the acceptance of Christianity by Rus are being held in Kyiv in an atmosphere of disrespect toward the Russian Orthodox Church and the feelings of millions of Orthodox believers in Russia and Ukraine."


HISTORY, RELIGION AND LANGUAGE – KEEP YOUR EYE ON THE BALL
John Marone

22.07.2008

Remember the shell game, in which the unsuspecting player is challenged to follow a little ball with his eyes as it rolls from under one shell to the next with lightning speed? When the game operator finally stops, the player is asked to guess which shell the ball lies under in order to win a prize. However, in most cases, the operator has already managed to slip the ball into his own hands, thereby making any guess by the player a losing one.


VICIOUS CIRCLE
Boris Kagarlitsky

17.07.2008

The Russian foreign policy boringly runs around in circles: the row with Estonia on the historic past, the squabbles between Moscow and Kyiv over the Crimea and Russia’s Black Sea Fleet, the confrontation with Georgia because of its breakaway republics etc. After having made a full circle we are back to square one - another conflict with Georgia.


SMILEY FACE ON A FOOTBALL
John Marone

08.07.2008

If there is one thing that has been hard to change in independent Ukraine, it's the country's image. Maybe that's why Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko, who has seen his own near demigod image from the 2004 Orange Revolution reduced to that of a mere man desperate to be re-elected, is so keen on successfully hosting the European football championship in 2012.


PLAYING UP TO PUTIN
John Marone

01.07.2008

Last weekend saw the visit of Ukrainian Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko to Moscow, where she met with Vladimir Putin for the first time since he went from being Russia’s president to heading his country’s government. During the joint press conference both premiers chose their words carefully, demonstrating the sensitivity of current Russian-Ukrainian relations.


EMBARRASSMENT IN THE KREMLIN
Boris Kagarlitsky

03.06.2008

Despite the propaganda declarations that Russia has finally “risen from the knees” and “returned its status of a superpower”, the Kremlin’s foreign policy is still characterized by inconsistency and complete absence of strategic planning. True, there has been perceptible change since the 1990s – the Kremlin has become more independent in decision-making, the Russian elite are aware of the state interests.


RUSSIAN PREMIER VISITS KYIV: DID HE CALL AT A BAD TIME?
John Marone

06.05.2008

Russian Prime Minister Viktor Zubkov led a government delegation to Kyiv on April 25. It was only a one-day visit, and Zubkov is expected to be replaced sometime this month anyway, following the inauguration of the new Russian president.


GEORGIA COULD BE OBSTREPEROUS OVER RUSSIA’S WTO BID
Jules Evans

20.11.2006

The Georgian government has apparently been offering olive branches to the Russian government over the last two weeks, with the demotion of hawkish defence minister Irakli Okruashvili to the ministry of economy (he’s since resigned).



Our authors
  Ivan  Gayvanovych, Kiev

THE EXCHANGE

27 April 2010


Geopolitical influence is an expensive thing. The Soviet Union realized that well supporting the Communist regimes and movements all over the world including Cuba and North Korea. The current Russian authorities also understood that when they agreed that Ukraine would not pay Russia $40 billion for the gas in return for extension of the lease allowing Russia's Black Sea Fleet to be stationed in the Crimea.



  Aleh  Novikau, Minsk

KYRGYZ SYNDROME

20 April 2010


The case of Kurmanbek Bakiyev is consistent with the logic of the Belarusian authorities’ actions towards the plane crash near Smolensk. The decisions not to demonstrate the “Katyn” film and not to announce the mourning were made emotionally, to spite Moscow and Warsaw, without thinking about their consequences and about reaction of the society and the neighbouring countries.



  Akram  Murtazaev, Moscow

EXPLOSIONS IN RUSSIA

16 April 2010


Explosions take place in Russia again. The last week of March started with terrorist acts at the Moscow metro stations which were followed by blasts in the Dagestani city of Kizlar. The horror spread from the metro to the whole city.



  John  Marone, Kyiv

POOR RELATIONS – THE UKRAINIAN GOVERNMENT GOES TO MOSCOW

29 March 2010


Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych symbolically selected Brussels as his first foreign visit upon taking the oath of office in what can only be seen as an exercise in public relations. The new government of Prime Minister Mykola Azarov headed straight for Moscow shortly thereafter with the sole intention of cutting a deal.



  Boris  Kagarlitsky, Moscow

THE WRATH DAY LIKE A GROUNDHOG DAY

25 March 2010


The protest actions, which the Russian extraparliamentary opposition had scheduled for March 20, were held as planned, they surprised or frightened nobody. Just as it had been expected, the activists of many organizations supporting the Wrath Day took to the streets… but saw there only the policemen, journalists and each other.



  Jules  Evans, London

COLD SNAP AFTER SPRING IN THE MIDDLE EAST

17 June 2009


As I write, angry demonstrations continue in Tehran and elsewhere in the Islamic Republic of Iran, over what the young demonstrators perceive as the blatant rigging of the presidential election to keep Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in power for another five years. Reports suggest at least eight protestors have been killed by police.



  Kevin  O'Flynn, Moscow

THE TERRIBLE C-WORD

08 December 2008


The cri… no the word will not be uttered. Now that President Medvedev and Prime Minister Putin have finally allowed themselves to belatedly use the word, it’s becoming increasingly difficult for me to spit it out of these lips. It’s c-this and c-that. If there was C-Span in Russia then it would be c-ing all day and all night long.



 events
 news
 opinion
 expert forum
 digest
 hot topics
 analysis
 databases
 about us
 the Eurasia Heritage Foundation projects
 links
 our authors
Eurasia Heritage Foundation