Main page                           
Eurasian Home - analytical resource


GALLUP: AMERICANS SOUR ON RUSSIA; RUSSIANS UNSURE ABOUT U.S.

Print version

Majority of Americans negative on Russia; many Russians undecided about U.S. leadership

As President Barack Obama meets with Russian President Dmitry Medvedev and Prime Minister Vladimir Putin in Moscow this week, a review of 2009 Gallup data shows that 53% of Americans have an unfavorable view of Russia and 34% of Russians negatively assess the performance of the leadership of the United States.

The current 53% unfavorable view of Russia among Americans is as high as it has been in nine years. But the 34% of Russians who disapprove of U.S. leadership is lower than in previous years, as more Russians this year indicate they don't yet have an opinion of U.S. leadership.

Gallup has been assessing Americans' views of Russia using a favorable/unfavorable format since 1989. (The survey question asked about the "Soviet Union" between 1989 and 1992, and then about "Russia" in the years since.) The latest assessment, from February of this year, finds that 40% of Americans have a favorable view of Russia. This represents the most negative assessment since November 2000. However, a March 2003 poll showed favorable and unfavorable ratings within one percentage point of the current results. Favorable opinions of Russia were as high 66% in February 2002. With the exception of the March 2003 poll (a time period just after the initial U.S. invasion of Iraq when Americans' views about several European countries that chose not to back the invasion plummeted), a majority of Americans had a favorable opinion in each annual February survey between 2001 and 2007. In 2008, favorable opinions of Russia dropped to 48%, with unfavorable opinions at 46%. This year, as noted, Americans' views of Russia became more negative still.

The current readings are not the most negative on record. Americans' views of Russia were more negative than the current views in two surveys conducted in 1999. The low ratings in 1999 reflect a time during which there was great turmoil in Russia and when embattled Russian President Boris Yeltsin ultimately yielded power to Vladimir Putin late that year.

In this year's survey, Republicans are slightly more negative about Russia than are independents or Democrats. However, at least a plurality of all three groups are more negative than positive in their assessment of Russia.

 

Russian Attitudes About U.S. Leadership

The Gallup Poll also assesses U.S.-Russian relations by asking about Russians' views of U.S. leadership.

Based on interviewing conducted April through June, this year's results show two significant findings compared with the trend over the three previous years.

  • First, the percentage of Russians who say they don't have an opinion of U.S. leadership has gone up significantly, from 30% in the previous three years to 47% this year.
  • Second, opinion has shifted in a positive direction, even though the disapprovals continue to outweigh the approvals. The percentage disapproving this year fell to 34% and the percentage approving rose to 20%, meaning that the uptick in the percentage of Russians with no opinion of American leadership strongly correlates with a decrease in the percentage who disapproves.

Looked at differently, the data show that the ratios of approval to disapproval for 2006, 2007, and 2008 were .28, .16, and .24, respectively. This year, the ratio has risen to .59, a markedly more positive result.

Implications

The most reasonable explanation for the sharp increase in percentage of Russians who say they do not have an opinion of U.S. leadership is the change in U.S. presidents. Apparently, an increased percentage of the Russian people are withholding judgment on President Obama's new administration. No doubt this stands in contrast to the well-established (and quite negative) image of the George W. Bush administration as it entered its sixth, seventh, and eighth years. The positive news for Obama as he meets with Russian leadership in Moscow this week is that initial impressions among those who do have an opinion appear to have shifted more in the positive direction than was the case for the last three years of the Bush administration.

At the same time, the less positive news for Russian leadership is the finding that Americans have become more negative about Russia in recent years, to the point where a majority now say their image of Russia is unfavorable. These negative images are as strong as they have been in almost a decade.

The overall affect of the meeting of the minds underway in Moscow this week is unknown at this point. Of course, it is possible that if Obama and the two Russian leaders appear to strike strong chords of cooperation and friendship, citizens of the U.S. and Russia could become more positive about the other country in the months ahead. One would expect that whatever the outcome of this week's talks, Russians will be more likely to have an opinion (either positive or negative) of U.S. leadership than was the case a few months ago.

Survey Methods

Russian results based on face-to-face interviews with 2,042 adults in Russia, aged 15 and older, conducted April-June 2009. For results based on the total sample of national adults, one can say with 95% confidence that the maximum margin of sampling error is ±2.5 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

U.S. results are based on telephone interviews with 1,022 national adults, aged 18 and older, conducted Feb. 9-12, 2009. For results based on the total sample of national adults, one can say with 95% confidence that the maximum margin of sampling error is ±3 percentage points.

Interviews are conducted with respondents on landline telephones (for respondents with a landline telephone) and cellular phones (for respondents who are cell phone only).

In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Frank NEWPORT

“Gallup.com”, July 6, 2009




Other materials on this topic
Hot topics
Digest

06.04.2009

THE GEORGIAN TIMES: RESETTING RELATIONS. GEORGIA NOT A BARGAINING CHIP

The first face-to-face talks between Barack Obama and Dmitry Medvedev were expected to shed light on what the notion of the “reset button” for US-Russian relationships promulgated by US Vice-President Joe Biden was really about.

16.03.2009

THE GEORGIAN TIMES: “THERE IS A THREAT OF INTERNATIONAL ISOLATION FOR GEORGIA”

Interview with Irakli Alasania, leader of the Alliance for Georgia.

19.01.2009

THE GEORGIAN TIMES: INTERVIEW WITH ARIEL COHEN

The US-Georgia Charter is not a Mutual Defence Pact. But It Draws Red Line for Russia.

12.01.2009

THE GEORGIAN TIMES: UNITED STATES-GEORGIA CHARTER ON STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP

Deepening Georgia’s integration into Euro-Atlantic institutions is a mutual priority, and we plan to undertake a program of enhanced security cooperation intended to increase Georgian capabilities and to strengthen Georgia’s candidacy for NATO membership.

01.12.2008

WORLD SECURITY NETWORK: OBAMA - PARADIGM CHANGE FOR RUSSIA NEEDED

I fear that in the U.S., too few understand the political and psychological problems of the Russians after the collapse of the USSR, the phantom pains of millions, and the problems of a massive country whose capital is nearly as close to Washington as to Vladivostok.

11.11.2008

RFE/RL: WITH OBAMA WIN, NATO PROSPECTS FOR UKRAINE, GEORGIA APPEAR TO SHIFT

Barack Obama's election may have prompted celebrations from Chicago to Nairobi. But in Tbilisi, it was disappointment that carried the day, with many Georgians ruefully contemplating what John McCain's defeat would mean for them.


Expert forum
OBAMA ADMINISTRATION’S FOREIGN POLICY TOWARDS SOUTH CAUCASUS

ALEXANDER ISKANDARYAN

08.07.2009

It is hard for the U.S.A. and other Western countries not to take into account Russia’s interests in the South Caucasus. In case there were any illusions in this respect, the five days war between Russia and Georgia in August 2008 has dispelled them.


NEITHER THE U.S.A., NOR RUSSIA ARE INTERESTED IN THE ESCALATION OF POLITICAL CONFLICT IN GEORGIA

DAVID LOSABERIDZE

03.07.2009

The situation in Georgia will be one of the issues of the negotiations between Russian President Dmitry Medvedev and U.S. President Barack Obama which will be held on July 6 in Moscow.


IS IT POSSIBLE TO IMPROVE THE RUSSIA-US RELATIONS?

MARIA YULIKOVA

29.05.2009

US president Barack Obama will travel to Moscow in July this year for his second negotiations round with Russian president Dmitry Medvedev. The first meeting between the two leaders in London in April went well.


RESET AT THE EXPENSE OF RULE OF LAW AND HUMAN RIGHTS?

MARIA YULIKOVA

08.04.2009

On April 1, 2009 Baraсk Obama met with the Russian leader Dmitry Medvedev to establish agenda for the future bilateral cooperation. Although the presidents agreed on a number of critical issues, the human rights violations and lack of rule of law in Russia were obviously put aside.


U.S.A. DOES NOT RECOGNIZE THE POST-SOVIET SPACE AS RUSSIA’S INFLUENCE AREA

ALEXANDER RONDELI

07.04.2009

The U.S. will not throw away its allies including Georgia for the sake of "reset" of the relations with Russia.


THE U.S. POLICY TOWARDS THE SOUTH CAUCASUS

ALEXANDER ISKANDARYAN

24.02.2009

There are no new tendencies or changes in the U.S. policy towards the South Caucasus after the new U.S. Administration has been formed. Barack Obama has not worked out his South Caucasian policy yet. For the time being, the new U.S. authorities focus on overcoming the economic crisis.


THE U.S.A. IS CHANGING ITS POLICY TOWARDS CENTRAL ASIA

AZAMAT TEMIRKULOV

18.02.2009

Washington is altering its attitude to the Central Asian region in the context of Afghanistan. The main cause is to ensure routes to transfer the American cargo to Afghanistan.


IMPROVEMENT OF THE U.S.-RUSSIA RELATIONS IS GOOD FOR UKRAINE

VALERY CHALIY

17.02.2009

Ukraine doesn’t want to be affected by the problems caused by the U.S.-Russia bad relations. This is one of the reasons why Ukraine is to welcome the fact that the issue of cutbacks in the nuclear arsenal can become of importance to the U.S.A. and Russia again.


U.S. – GEORGIA RELATIONS UNDER THE BARACK OBAMA ADMINISTRATION

ALEXANDER RONDELI

26.01.2009

In the eyes of the U.S. Administration Saakashvili represents the guarantor of stability and further development. If Saakashvili slowly but steadily promotes democratization in the country, he has nothing to worry about.


U.S. - RUSSIA RELATIONS UNDER THE NEW U.S. ADMINISTRATION

VIKTOR KREMENIUK

23.01.2009

The rivalry between Moscow and Washington regarding the post-Soviet space will be still urgent under President Obama, but it won’t be crucial as it was under the previous Administration. A certain compromise is possible to achieve.


DOES THE US–GEORGIA CHARTER ON STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP CHALLENGE RUSSIA?

ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE

14.01.2009

It is difficult to forecast how diligently the Administration of President Barack Obama will follow the above-mentioned articles of the Charter. But there is a high probability (taking into consideration the increased tension in the Russia-U.S. relations) that Russia would consider the Charter as a challenge to its interests in South Caucasus.


PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION IN THE USA

SERGEI ROGOV

11.11.2008

Barack Obama is an outstanding policy-maker. He was considered to be a classical marginal politician, who had nothing to do with the U.S. political establishment and who was not taken seriously. But he felt that the U.S. voters expected changes.


WILL THE US-RUSSIA RELATIONS BE RESTORED?

MARIA YULIKOVA

06.11.2008

Two months of blaming rhetoric between Russia and the US leaders, prompted by the August Caucasus crisis, nearly annihilated all the diplomatic achievements in the relationships between the two countries of the current millennium, and caused frustration among the diplomats on both sides.


RUSSIA-U.S. RELATIONS: WHAT NEXT?

DMITRY TRENIN, ALEXEI ARBATOV

06.10.2008

According to Russia’s President Dmitry Medvedev, the armed conflict between Georgia and Russia has changed the world. This may be an exaggeration, but in fact the war has changed the Russian foreign policy, it deeply influences Russia’s economy and Moscow's relations with the West and the New Independent States.


UNITED STATES AND NATO RE-ENGAGEMENT WITH UZBEKISTAN

ROGER N MCDERMOTT

01.10.2008

Current re-engagement between the U.S., NATO and Uzbekistan may be characterised as officially cautious and low key.


RIVALRY BETWEEN THE USA AND RUSSIA FOR THE POST-SOVIET SPACE

VIKTOR KREMENIUK

04.09.2008

The Caucasian conflict indicates intense rivalry between the USA and Russia for the post-Soviet space. Russia still hopes to put an end to the expansion of the U.S. influence.



Opinion
BARACK OBAMA - KING FOR A DAY
John Marone

10.11.2008

The buzz over the election of America's first black president, Barack Obama, continues unabated. Fresh faced, eloquent and from a modest background, his 'story' sells well just about everywhere. But being liked so much for doing so little is a little like being king for a day, secretly hoping that the reality of tomorrow never has to come.


LOOKING FOR A RUSSIAN OBAMA
Kevin O'Flynn

05.11.2008

When were you last excited about an election in Russia? Any election? I've seen four presidential elections in Russia and the only one that had any excitement was in 1996 when many feared a Communist victory would swing the country back to its Soviet past.



 events
 news
 opinion
 expert forum
 digest
 hot topics
 analysis
 databases
 about us
 the Eurasia Heritage Foundation projects
 links
 our authors
Eurasia Heritage Foundation