Main page                           
Eurasian Home - analytical resource



JOHN  MARONE, KYIV
NO MORE SUPERPOWER PLAYOFFS

Print version               


For centuries, Ukraine's Cossacks were able to play off the superpowers of their time: The Turks against the Russians, or the Poles against both. Some would argue that the survival of the Ukrainian nation depended on a 'flexible' foreign policy. Unfortunately, the result of this policy was a culture of persistent internal division that eventually led to Russian domination. No sooner had Ukraine regained its independence in 1991 than it began to play Russia off again, this time against the United States and Europe. Instead of offering their country's soldiers as mercenaries, Ukrainian leaders now advertise its value as an energy corridor, a market of 46 million people or a strategic location for a military base. But these same leaders are no more united around a national strategy than they were 300 years ago, and today's superpowers might very well end up sorting out their affairs without consideration of Ukrainian interests. Essentially, there are two possible outcomes of post-Soviet relations between Russia and the West, and neither bodes particularly well for an independent Ukraine.

Possible outcome No. 1 entails a rapprochement of the world's military superpowers - the United States and Russia.

Ever since oil prices started going through the roof, and Mr. Putin took control of the country, Russia has attempted to regain its international status, especially vis-à-vis America. First, the Kremlin put down any internal dissent, and then it started putting pressure on the so-called near abroad, or its former satellite states. In doing so, it ran head on into a Bush administration enjoying the geopolitical windfalls from the wave of democratic, or colored, revolutions that erupted along Russia's underbelly following 9-11. Now, America is more concerned with plugging its gaping financial crisis at home, further aggravated by the cost of conducting two wars against an all but invisible enemy. If it weren't for the fact that the global financial crisis affecting America has been equally detrimental to Russia, including the lowering of world oil prices, the Kremlin staff would be dancing on Red Square. But, alas, both Washington and Moscow have seen better times.

And as leaders from both countries tally the losses, along with the rest of the world, it probably wouldn't be too much of a flight of fancy to imagine them looking disdainfully at a map of Ukraine. To the United States, the democratic hopes engendered by the Orange Revolution have been squandered by Orange Ukrainian leaders. To be sure, the new Obama administration cannot just concede Ukraine as part of Russia's much trumpeted 'sphere of influence', but it wouldn't be out of place to now ask: who wants Ukraine now anyway? With the pro-American President Yushchenko exploring new depths of unpopularity at home and abroad, and his leading opponents firmly in the pro-Russian camp or intently pointed in that direction, whom would Obama support in Kyiv anyway? 

For a time, it seemed like Washington was building an energy corridor of newly independent states from the Caucasus to the Baltics, but almost every link in the chain is weak; U.S. support for an independent Georgia has turned into support for the floundering Saakashvili administration; Ukraine has allowed the corrupt interests of its oligarchs to undermine its own energy security, not to mention that of Europe; while Poland and the Baltics are better suited to criticizing Russia's role in supplying energy to Europe than offering an alternative to it. For a variety of reasons, including putting Americans to work, Obama might begin concentrating US efforts on developing alternative sources of fuel rather than securing hydrocarbons so far from home.   

Regarding Ukraine's potential as a strategic military power, the people at NATO are already in retreat. Last week, it was announced outright that Kyiv would not be offered an Action Plan (seen as the last step on the way to eventual membership) this year. The news is actually a follow-up on European leaders' cold reception to the idea during the Bucharest summit last spring. As George Bush wraps up his last days in office, his European policy initiatives are being packed up as well. No one should be surprised if Mr. Obama derails Bush's plan to install a missile defense system in Eastern Europe.

Of course, neither the United States nor Europe wants to give Moscow a green light to bully former Soviet republics. But there seems to be a growing realization that Russia should be brought on board to battle greater threats to the West. On December 8, NATO special representative Roberts Simmons announced in Moscow that the shipment of military cargo through Russia to NATO troops in Afghanistan is a 'priority', particularly as supply routes from Pakistan become more precarious.     

Stepping back from last summer's Georgian war, the U.S. and Russia have more reasons to be friends than allies. Cooperation in the so-called war on terror, containment of China and a nuclear Iran, development of Russia's energy fields and a continuation of partnership in space are issues immediately understandable across the spectrum of U.S. policy makers and the American public - much more understandable than supporting democracy in a corruption ridden and schizophrenic Ukraine.       

Possible outcome No. 2 entails a closer relationship between the EU and Russia, to the exclusion (to one degree or another) of the United States. 

The popularity of President-Elect Obama in Europe is likely more due to the departure of Mr. Bush than to any hope for a real improvement in trans-Atlantic relations. Europeans blame their cousins across the ocean for everything from the current financial crisis to global warning. Ever since the end of World War Two, there has been a European resentment of American military and financial power. The war in Iraq marked a low point in American leadership.

The deterioration of EU-American relations also coincided with increasing European confidence (especially the strength of the euro), as well as assertive engagement by Russia (which supplies the EU with around a quarter of its gas). All this doesn't mean that the Europeans will want to replace an overbearing U.S. with a capitalist Soviet Union. But it does mean that America isn't the only big brother in town.

Russia offers Europe badly needed hydrocarbons as well as a market for EU goods. Not everyone is satisfied with the Kremlin's democratic credentials, but lead countries (and major gas customers) like Germany and Italy aren't complaining. After all, it's America that started the global financial crisis and war in Iraq, the Kremlin has been quick to point out. Russia has even tried to present itself as a regional militiaman, taking the initiative in the fight against Somalian pirates. When the price of oil starts rising again, Moscow may even prove to be better capable of financing an enhanced role in Europe.

Even a partial reduction in American influence in Europe bodes badly for Ukraine's Western integration efforts. Despite its obligatory lip service to democratic ideals, Brussels is more interested in its energy security. Ukraine is still the major transit route for Russian fuels, but alternative pipelines are already under construction. And unlike America, the Europeans don't want to be in Afghanistan, much less set up a launching platform into southern Asia from the former Soviet Union. Already, Ukraine's internal politics is adjusting to the new political reality, with President Yushchenko's former Orange ally, Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko, chumming up to Moscow, in competition with the Kremlin's traditional Ukrainian ally, former Prime Minister Viktor Yanukovych.

U.S. influence in Eastern Europe or anywhere else is not going to go away over night, despite the country's difficult economic times. But Ukraine's ability to flirt with America while remaining in the Russian fold is already being curtailed, quite possibly along with the country's prospects for remaining independent.

John Marone, a columnist of Eurasian Home website, Kyiv, Ukraine

December 10, 2008



Our readers’ comments



There are no comments on this article.

You will be the first.

Send a comment

Other materials on this topic
Hot topics
Digest

17.11.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: COERCION TO ACTION

It is pointless to debate about who was behind Yatsenyuk’s dismissal – Yushchenko or his alter-ego Baloha: if Yushchenko had not profited from his confidant, he would have long sacrificed him.

11.11.2008

RFE/RL: WITH OBAMA WIN, NATO PROSPECTS FOR UKRAINE, GEORGIA APPEAR TO SHIFT

Barack Obama's election may have prompted celebrations from Chicago to Nairobi. But in Tbilisi, it was disappointment that carried the day, with many Georgians ruefully contemplating what John McCain's defeat would mean for them.

31.10.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: CURE YOURSELF?

The Ukrainian leadership has once again proven to be helpless. Even the real threat of a catastrophic financial and economic crisis has not consolidated the key political leaders who still follow the principle of collective irresponsibility.

13.10.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: EARLY ELECTION IN UKRAINE - DANGEROUS EXPERIMENT

This article does not assess the behavior of major Ukrainian political forces and their leaders as much has been and will be written about that. My point is that these all-versus-all political games obscure important economic problems which tend to aggravate underlying conditions of political instability.

06.10.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: GAS CUSHION

On 2 October 2008, thanks to long preparatory work, negotiations between Russian and Ukrainian prime ministers, Yuliya Tymoshenko and Vladimir Putin took place after all, and were fairly successful.

04.10.2008

GALLUP.COM: UKRAINIANS MAY OPPOSE PRESIDENT’S PRO-WESTERN GOALS

A Gallup Poll found a strong majority of Ukrainians (65%) saying their leadership is taking the country in the wrong direction and only about one in six (16%) expressing confidence in their national government.

26.09.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: THE BEES AND THE BONNET

Yulia Tymoshenko and Viktor Yanukovych do deserve a good deal of criticism, but Viktor Yushchenko bears the heaviest brunt of responsibility as the guarantor of the Constitution and the “arbiter of the nation.”

22.09.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: THERE WAS A WISE MAN OF…
Yet another preterm parliamentary election is looming on the horizon while politicians are still unable to choose their course. A new coalition (whatever its configuration) ought to crown their efforts.

15.09.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: FIELD REPORTS

This week all those involved in the current stage of the permanent Ukrainian political crisis played a kind of make-believe game. Inside Ukraine the President made believe a coup d’etat and in Europe he made believe “a normal democratic process.”

20.06.2008

RUSSIA IN GLOBAL AFFAIRS: A SPECIAL CASE?

Ukraine, in the wake of its Orange Revolution, has earned the image of a leading post-Soviet country regarding the pace of liberal reform. However, this perception of the country is to a large extent a kind of payment in advance rather than a reflection of actual results.

25.12.2007

ZERKALO NEDELI: LIFE BETWEEN ELECTIONS
The fact that the upcoming year will be year of the Earth Rat is welcome news to Yuliya Tymoshenko: she was born in 1960, the year of Iron Rat. So in an astrological sense, it will be her year.

Expert forum
VERKHOVNA RADA OF UKRAINE ELECTED A NEW SPEAKER

DMITRY VYDRIN, VADIM KARASYOV, IGOR BURAKOVSKY

10.12.2008

The Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine has elected a new Speaker, Volodymyr Lytvyn. But an amorphous majority is created instead of the new coalition. Moreover, this majority cannot be regarded as the ‘orange’ coalition.


ECONOMIC CRISIS UNITES YULIYA TYMOSHENKO BLOC AND PARTY OF REGIONS

VITALY BALA

05.12.2008

The potential Yuliya Tymoshenko Bloc and the Party of Regions alliance can be created formally or informally. Regardless of the alliance format, this would be the best scenario because then the presidential campaign would be free of stark confrontations.


VERKHOVNA RADA OF UKRAINE ELECTS A NEW SPEAKER

YURY YAKIMENKO

19.11.2008

A parliamentary majority should be formed in order to elect a new speaker of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. This majority could become a new coalition.


EARLY PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS IN UKRAINE. CURRENT DEVELOPMENTS

VADIM KARASYOV, MIKHAIL POGREBINSKY, VITALY PORTNIKOV

17.10.2008

There is a question about the situation after the elections. But why should it change? If the elections outcome is about the same as in the last elections (the public opinion polls show that), the Party of Regions and Our Ukraine will not have the majority to build a coalition. 


DISSOLUTION OF THE VERKHOVNA RADA: POSSIBILITIES AND RISKS

VITALY BALA

15.10.2008

Yuliya Tymoshenko Bloc and Prime Minister Yuliya Tymoshenko herself have reacted negatively to President Viktor Yushchenko’s decision to dissolve the Verkhovha Rada and to hold early parliamentary elections.


UKRAINE IS FORCED TO CHOOSE UNSTABILITY

STANISLAV PRITCHIN

14.10.2008

On October 8, in his message to the people President of Ukraine Viktor Yushchenko announced the dissolution of the Verkhovna Rada. His speech was based on the allegation that Yuliya Tymoshenko and her decisions “threaten Ukraine”.


THE BREAKUP OF THE 'ORANGE' COALITION

VITALY BALA

17.09.2008

The main reason for the breakup of the 'orange' coalition is that President of Ukraine Viktor Yushchenko does not want to accept Yuliya Tymoshenko's wide popularity in Ukraine.


THE FUTURE OF VIKTOR YUSHCHENKO AND POLITICAL CRISIS IN UKRAINE

VADIM KARASYOV, VITALY PORTNIKOV

16.09.2008

"Currently there are a few people in Ukraine backing Viktor Yushchenko’s nation building and cultural project, and if the early elections were called  the votes could be distributed, in the main, between the Party of Regions and Yuliya Tymoshenko Bloc," Vitaly Portnikov said.



Opinion
FROM POST-SOVIET BUFFER TO GANGSTER GAP
John Marone

24.11.2008

A report recently released by U.S. intelligence agencies predicts that American influence on the global stage will diminish over the next 15 years, as the rise of powers such as China, India and other third-world giants creates a more multi-polar planet. So where does Ukraine fit into this scenario?


UKRAINE'S INDEPENDENCE DEPENDENT ON RELATIONS WITH RUSSIA
John Marone

17.11.2008

Now, more than any time since the country gained independence 17 years ago, Ukraine looks destined to come back under Russian hegemony. Ironically, the more the pro-Western administration of President Viktor Yushchenko resists this outcome, the greater the chances of it coming about.


BARACK OBAMA - KING FOR A DAY
John Marone

10.11.2008

The buzz over the election of America's first black president, Barack Obama, continues unabated. Fresh faced, eloquent and from a modest background, his 'story' sells well just about everywhere. But being liked so much for doing so little is a little like being king for a day, secretly hoping that the reality of tomorrow never has to come.


DEMOCRATIC UNCERTAINTY BEFORE ELECTIONS IN AMERICA AND UKRAINE
John Marone

31.10.2008

The 2008 U.S. presidential-election campaign has been watched with much anticipation, both at home and abroad. There’s a woman vice president on the Republican ticket, and an African-American being fielded by the Democrats for the nation’s top job. Whichever party wins, history will be made.


UKRAINIAN LEADERS TURN THEIR BACKS ON FINANCIAL CRISIS
John Marone

27.10.2008

Along with Eastern Europe's other so-called emerging economies, Ukraine has been posting impressive rates of growth over the past several years. Now all that has been undone, and everyone is hoping that the International Monetary Fund will come to Ukraine's rescue.


UKRAINE'S PLAYGROUND POLITICS
John Marone

17.10.2008

With stability no where in sight and two more elections just around the corner, Ukraine's political playground is proving to be increasingly fractious. More importantly, the lunch mothers in the West are more concerned about a looming world recession, leaving Ukraine more and more to the over-protective oversight of Mother Russia.


ELECTIONS IN LIEU OF STABILITY
John Marone

09.10.2008

Ukraine is going to hold its fifth general elections in as many years, but don't expect the upcoming parliamentary vote to stabilize the country's chaotic political arena any time soon. Ever since President Viktor Yushchenko was elected on a pro-Western platform back in 2005, the seats of power in the former Soviet republic have been contested in a no-holds-barred dogfight that is desperate to the point of absurdity. 


THE EUROPEAN SUBCONTINENT
Ivan Gayvanovych

01.10.2008

In Transcarpathia, near the Ukrainian village of Delovoe, there are three geodetic signs indicating the geographic center of the European subcontinent. The first sign was put up in 1887 under Emperor Franz Joseph I of Austria. The second one was set up by the members of the Soviet Academy of Sciences. The third one was put up in the first years of Ukraine’s independence after the Soviet Union had collapsed.


HOW TO QUARREL WITH A NEIGHBOUR
Boris Kagarlitsky

11.09.2008

It seems that after the conflict with Georgia all we need is to clash with Ukraine. A lot of politicians both in Russia and Ukraine would definitely like it to happen. Caucasian crisis resulted in a new quarrel over Sevastopol, this time provoked by the Ukrainian side.


UKRAINE’S INDEFENSIBLE POSITION - IN THE WAKE OF GEORGIA
John Marone

01.09.2008

Since 1991, Ukraine has sat on the fence like a country coquette with her back to her jealous ex-husband Russia, from which the country’s ‘elite’ have nevertheless continued to get rich on cheap gas, while batting her eyes at the glamorous West, which offers lots of nice gifts but never a firm proposal of marriage.


ENOUGH GRAND-STANDING BY THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT
Jules Evans

27.08.2008

The typical criticism of the UK’s Foreign Office is the one eloquently expressed in John Le Carre’s The Constant Gardener - that they are pitiless practitioners of real-politik who care more about stability than idealism, and who only really work to protect the interests of British corporations, rather than British values. But on Russia, the Foreign Office seems to have erred on the other side.


PLAYING UP TO PUTIN
John Marone

01.07.2008

Last weekend saw the visit of Ukrainian Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko to Moscow, where she met with Vladimir Putin for the first time since he went from being Russia’s president to heading his country’s government. During the joint press conference both premiers chose their words carefully, demonstrating the sensitivity of current Russian-Ukrainian relations.


STICKING OUT THE UKRAINIAN TONGUE
John Marone

30.05.2008

The crusade to raise the Ukrainian language heads and shoulders above Russian continues apace in Kyiv and other parts of the country, but as with most crusades, it’s not clear what the end goal is. Ukraine’s State Cinema Service recently announced that all films made in Ukraine must be in Ukrainian starting in July. All foreign films shown in Ukraine are already required to be dubbed or subtitled in Ukrainian.



Our authors
  Ivan  Gayvanovych, Kiev

THE EXCHANGE

27 April 2010


Geopolitical influence is an expensive thing. The Soviet Union realized that well supporting the Communist regimes and movements all over the world including Cuba and North Korea. The current Russian authorities also understood that when they agreed that Ukraine would not pay Russia $40 billion for the gas in return for extension of the lease allowing Russia's Black Sea Fleet to be stationed in the Crimea.



  Aleh  Novikau, Minsk

KYRGYZ SYNDROME

20 April 2010


The case of Kurmanbek Bakiyev is consistent with the logic of the Belarusian authorities’ actions towards the plane crash near Smolensk. The decisions not to demonstrate the “Katyn” film and not to announce the mourning were made emotionally, to spite Moscow and Warsaw, without thinking about their consequences and about reaction of the society and the neighbouring countries.



  Akram  Murtazaev, Moscow

EXPLOSIONS IN RUSSIA

16 April 2010


Explosions take place in Russia again. The last week of March started with terrorist acts at the Moscow metro stations which were followed by blasts in the Dagestani city of Kizlar. The horror spread from the metro to the whole city.



  John  Marone, Kyiv

POOR RELATIONS – THE UKRAINIAN GOVERNMENT GOES TO MOSCOW

29 March 2010


Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych symbolically selected Brussels as his first foreign visit upon taking the oath of office in what can only be seen as an exercise in public relations. The new government of Prime Minister Mykola Azarov headed straight for Moscow shortly thereafter with the sole intention of cutting a deal.



  Boris  Kagarlitsky, Moscow

THE WRATH DAY LIKE A GROUNDHOG DAY

25 March 2010


The protest actions, which the Russian extraparliamentary opposition had scheduled for March 20, were held as planned, they surprised or frightened nobody. Just as it had been expected, the activists of many organizations supporting the Wrath Day took to the streets… but saw there only the policemen, journalists and each other.



  Jules  Evans, London

COLD SNAP AFTER SPRING IN THE MIDDLE EAST

17 June 2009


As I write, angry demonstrations continue in Tehran and elsewhere in the Islamic Republic of Iran, over what the young demonstrators perceive as the blatant rigging of the presidential election to keep Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in power for another five years. Reports suggest at least eight protestors have been killed by police.



  Kevin  O'Flynn, Moscow

THE TERRIBLE C-WORD

08 December 2008


The cri… no the word will not be uttered. Now that President Medvedev and Prime Minister Putin have finally allowed themselves to belatedly use the word, it’s becoming increasingly difficult for me to spit it out of these lips. It’s c-this and c-that. If there was C-Span in Russia then it would be c-ing all day and all night long.



 events
 news
 opinion
 expert forum
 digest
 hot topics
 analysis
 databases
 about us
 the Eurasia Heritage Foundation projects
 links
 our authors
Eurasia Heritage Foundation