Main page                           
Eurasian Home - analytical resource


WILL GEORGIA AND UKRAINE GET THE NATO MEMBERSHIP ACTION PLAN?

Print version

ALEKSANDR RAHR,
Director of Russia, Ukraine/CIS programs, German Council on Foreign Policy, Coordinator of the EU-Russia Forum (in cooperation with the European Commission), Germany

On 2-3 December 2008, Brussels will host the meeting of the Foreign Ministers of NATO member states. On the agenda of the meeting there will be the issue of granting the NATO Membership Action Plan to Georgia and Ukraine. A number of the EU member states are against this step.

The European countries do not want the USA to use them. One should realize that NATO is not a car owners club, but it is a military organization and each its member should identify itself with the others because NATO is to protect its member states in the case of an armed conflict.

Poland and the Baltic States, judging by their leaders’ statements, still live in the Cold War realities. But Germany, France, Italy and other European countries do not consider Russia to be their enemy.

Apart from that, it is George Bush’s Administration who wishes the decision on granting the NATO Membership Action Plan to Georgia and Ukraine to be taken as soon as possible. But Europe came to realize that those issues should be solved with new U.S. President, Barack Obama. The Republican Administration is interested in the positive decision because it would put up a ‘small monument’ to George Bush.  

Another reason why the European countries are skeptical about granting the NATO Membership Action Plan to Georgia and Ukraine is the situation in those two countries. Georgia has no democracy, and the European leadership understands it well. As regards Ukraine, its inhabitants’opinions about joining NATO are divided. Among the Ukrainians, there are a lot of supporters as well as opponents of that prospect.

December 1, 2008




Our readers’ comments



There are no comments on this article.

You will be the first.

Send a comment

Other materials on this topic
Hot topics
Digest

01.12.2008

WORLD SECURITY NETWORK: OBAMA - PARADIGM CHANGE FOR RUSSIA NEEDED

I fear that in the U.S., too few understand the political and psychological problems of the Russians after the collapse of the USSR, the phantom pains of millions, and the problems of a massive country whose capital is nearly as close to Washington as to Vladivostok.

11.11.2008

RFE/RL: WITH OBAMA WIN, NATO PROSPECTS FOR UKRAINE, GEORGIA APPEAR TO SHIFT

Barack Obama's election may have prompted celebrations from Chicago to Nairobi. But in Tbilisi, it was disappointment that carried the day, with many Georgians ruefully contemplating what John McCain's defeat would mean for them.

04.10.2008

GALLUP.COM: UKRAINIANS MAY OPPOSE PRESIDENT’S PRO-WESTERN GOALS

A Gallup Poll found a strong majority of Ukrainians (65%) saying their leadership is taking the country in the wrong direction and only about one in six (16%) expressing confidence in their national government.

15.09.2008

ACTION UKRAINE REPORT: WHAT DOES RUSSIA WANT? HOW DO WE RESPOND?

The lecture by Steven Pifer, Visiting Fellow of the Brookings Institution, on Russia's interests and influence in modern world and the ways for the U.S. government to reach the point in this key bilateral relationship.

14.07.2008

IP-INTERNATIONAL POLITICS: NATO SUMMIT 2008 - BUCHAREST'S BALANCE SHEET

The Bucharest summit was anything but the failure portrayed by some of the media. There was concrete progress in a number of crucial areas, including Afghanistan, NATO enlargement, and missile defense.

05.05.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: “UKRAINE WILL BECOME A NATO MEMBER AND WILL HAVE GOOD RELATIONS WITH RUSSIA”, VOLODYMYR OHRYZKO

Interview with Volodymyr Ohryzko, Minister of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine.

17.04.2008

IWPR: UZBEKS RE-ENGAGE WITH NATO

President Islam Karimov attended the NATO summit in Bucharest on April 2-4, and offered pact members the use of Uzbek territory as an overland route for supplying non-military material to Afghanistan.

15.04.2008

ZERKALO NEDELI: NATO STRENGTHENS UKRAINE AND ITSELF

"NATO has always taken Russia into account when considering the modalities of enlargement, the timing of it and the likely consequences of it. But it has never granted Russia a veto over this process or a role to play in it," James Sherr. 

14.04.2008

RFE/RL: NATO: KYIV, TBILISI FACE MORE OBSTACLES THAN SIMPLY RUSSIAN RESISTANCE

Days before the NATO summit in Bucharest began, Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili rolled out a new peace initiative for breakaway Abkhazia.

03.04.2008

RFE/RL: NATO WELCOMES CROATIA, ALBANIA, BUT ASKS UKRAINE, GEORGIA, MACEDONIA TO WAIT

Speaking today at NATO's summit in Bucharest, Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer said the alliance wants to welcome Ukraine and Georgia as members someday.

16.12.2007

THE GEORGIAN TIMES: NATIONAL VOTE: SHOULD GEORGIA BECOME A MEMBER OF NATO?

Georgian voters will have to answer a question if Georgia should become a member of NATO at the January 5th plebiscite, which will be held alongside the presidential poll.

02.05.2006

ZERKALO NEDELI: UKRAINE’S LONG WAY TO NATO

Kyiv actually dreamed of being invited to join the NATO Membership Action Plan (MAP) at the NATO foreign ministers’ meeting in Sofia, the Bulgarian capital. Yet it was not the alliance’s fault that it did not happen once again, despite numerous favorable conditions.


Expert forum
GEORGIA WAS REFUSED THE ADMISSION TO NATO MEMBERSHIP ACTION PLAN

ALEXANDER RONDELI

05.12.2008

The decision of the NATO Foreign Ministers meeting not to allow Georgia to join NATO Membership Action Plan did not surprise Tbilisi or anybody else. Georgia has received an annual plan for 2009, but its substance is not known. 


PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION IN THE USA

SERGEI ROGOV

11.11.2008

Barack Obama is an outstanding policy-maker. He was considered to be a classical marginal politician, who had nothing to do with the U.S. political establishment and who was not taken seriously. But he felt that the U.S. voters expected changes.


WILL THE US-RUSSIA RELATIONS BE RESTORED?

MARIA YULIKOVA

06.11.2008

Two months of blaming rhetoric between Russia and the US leaders, prompted by the August Caucasus crisis, nearly annihilated all the diplomatic achievements in the relationships between the two countries of the current millennium, and caused frustration among the diplomats on both sides.


RUSSIA-U.S. RELATIONS: WHAT NEXT?

DMITRY TRENIN, ALEXEI ARBATOV

06.10.2008

According to Russia’s President Dmitry Medvedev, the armed conflict between Georgia and Russia has changed the world. This may be an exaggeration, but in fact the war has changed the Russian foreign policy, it deeply influences Russia’s economy and Moscow's relations with the West and the New Independent States.


UNITED STATES AND NATO RE-ENGAGEMENT WITH UZBEKISTAN

ROGER N MCDERMOTT

01.10.2008

Current re-engagement between the U.S., NATO and Uzbekistan may be characterised as officially cautious and low key.


"WEST SHOULD ADMIT THAT RUSSIA HAS ITS OWN INTERESTS"

ALEKSANDR RAHR

22.09.2008

The USA, where the presidential election campaign goes full swing, tries to take the toughest possible line with Russia. In many respects that is why some American government officials seek to support Georgian leader Mikheil Saakashvili.


THE OUTCOME OF THE EXTRAORDINARY EU SUMMIT ON SOUTH OSSETIAN CONFLICT

VLADIMIR CHIZHOV

03.09.2008

The outcome of the extraordinary EU summit held on September 1 in Brussels was more or less predictable, both in terms of the views expressed by the EU member states and in terms of the EU Presidency conclusion.


MOSCOW’S REALITIES AND THE FUTURE OF GEORGIAN SOVEREIGNTY

GEORGETA POURCHOT

20.08.2008

The current Russian military operation in Georgia marks the beginning of the end for Georgian sovereignty. The peace deal brokered by France contains the seeds of further chipping away at Georgian territory.


“SEA BREEZE-2008” AND PROSPECTS OF UKRAINE’S JOINING NATO

VITALY PORTNIKOV

22.07.2008

The holding of “Sea Breeze” military exercises and Ukraine’s joining NATO should be regarded as two different processes. Some people want to unite them, but Kyiv has not applied for the NATO membership yet. Ukraine has not received the NATO Membership Action Plan and, apparently, will not recieve it in December.


DOES NATO ENLARGEMENT POSE A THREAT TO RUSSIA?

KONSTANTIN ZATULIN, ALEXANDER KONOVALOV, TATYANA PARKHALINA, OLES DONIY, LEONID KOZHARA, IVAN ZAETS, ANDREW KUCHINS

07.04.2008

"Why do the Central and Eastern European countries seek to join NATO? For many of them it is a way to join the EU. Many countries took this as institutionalization of independence from Moscow. For many countries it was a way to return to Europe," Tatyana Parkhalina.


NATO, THE CIS AND RUSSIA AFTER BUCHAREST

STEPHEN BLANK

02.04.2008

In advance of NATO’s Bucharest summit Russia has decided to employ the traditional Soviet tactics of intimidation and blackmail to block NATO’s enlargement.


NATO-RUSSIA BREAK: A SIGNIFICANT POSSIBILITY

GEORGETA POURCHOT

01.04.2008

The Bucharest NATO summit offers a significant possibility that NATO’s and Russia’s positions on a variety of issues will further diverge, marking the beginning of the end of this uneven relationship.


EURASIA RISING: DEMOCRACY AND INDEPENDENCE IN THE POST-SOVIET SPACE

GEORGETA POURCHOT

14.03.2008

Eurasian Home website with a kind permission of the Greenwood Publishing Group Inc., publishes the first chapter "Sovereignity from Within" of the book "Eurasia Rising: Democracy and Independence in the Post-Soviet Space" by the Eurasian Home website contributor Georgeta Pourchot.


RUSSIA-NATO: PROSPECTS OF COOPERATION

VYACHESLAV IGRUNOV

01.06.2007

One of the major issues directly concerning the relations between Russia and NATO is the Alliance’s enlargement and accession of new members, the former Soviet republics (Ukraine and Georgia) to the Alliance.


GEORGIA – NATO: PROSPECTS FOR COOPERATION

MERAB PACHULIA

09.03.2007

Ambitions of the Georgian authorities to develop cooperation with NATO are largely supported by the population. There is a consensus on the benefits that the country could receive after acquiring membership of the Alliance, though contradictions remain.


GEORGIA’S WAY TO NATO STREAMLINED

ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE

19.02.2007

Members of the “National Forum” and some other opposition parties fear that Georgia may join NATO without Abkhazia and South Ossetia, thus losing those territories for good.


NATO AND RUSSIA’S BALANCING ACT

GEORGETA POURCHOT

02.05.2006

NATO’s most recent informal summit in Sophia underscores a decade and a half of balancing act between two former adversaries, the North Atlantic Alliance and Russia.



Opinion
FROM POST-SOVIET BUFFER TO GANGSTER GAP
John Marone

24.11.2008

A report recently released by U.S. intelligence agencies predicts that American influence on the global stage will diminish over the next 15 years, as the rise of powers such as China, India and other third-world giants creates a more multi-polar planet. So where does Ukraine fit into this scenario?


BARACK OBAMA - KING FOR A DAY
John Marone

10.11.2008

The buzz over the election of America's first black president, Barack Obama, continues unabated. Fresh faced, eloquent and from a modest background, his 'story' sells well just about everywhere. But being liked so much for doing so little is a little like being king for a day, secretly hoping that the reality of tomorrow never has to come.


DEMOCRATIC UNCERTAINTY BEFORE ELECTIONS IN AMERICA AND UKRAINE
John Marone

31.10.2008

The 2008 U.S. presidential-election campaign has been watched with much anticipation, both at home and abroad. There’s a woman vice president on the Republican ticket, and an African-American being fielded by the Democrats for the nation’s top job. Whichever party wins, history will be made.


THE EUROPEAN SUBCONTINENT
Ivan Gayvanovych

01.10.2008

In Transcarpathia, near the Ukrainian village of Delovoe, there are three geodetic signs indicating the geographic center of the European subcontinent. The first sign was put up in 1887 under Emperor Franz Joseph I of Austria. The second one was set up by the members of the Soviet Academy of Sciences. The third one was put up in the first years of Ukraine’s independence after the Soviet Union had collapsed.


UKRAINE’S INDEFENSIBLE POSITION - IN THE WAKE OF GEORGIA
John Marone

01.09.2008

Since 1991, Ukraine has sat on the fence like a country coquette with her back to her jealous ex-husband Russia, from which the country’s ‘elite’ have nevertheless continued to get rich on cheap gas, while batting her eyes at the glamorous West, which offers lots of nice gifts but never a firm proposal of marriage.


ENOUGH GRAND-STANDING BY THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT
Jules Evans

27.08.2008

The typical criticism of the UK’s Foreign Office is the one eloquently expressed in John Le Carre’s The Constant Gardener - that they are pitiless practitioners of real-politik who care more about stability than idealism, and who only really work to protect the interests of British corporations, rather than British values. But on Russia, the Foreign Office seems to have erred on the other side.


VICIOUS CIRCLE
Boris Kagarlitsky

17.07.2008

The Russian foreign policy boringly runs around in circles: the row with Estonia on the historic past, the squabbles between Moscow and Kyiv over the Crimea and Russia’s Black Sea Fleet, the confrontation with Georgia because of its breakaway republics etc. After having made a full circle we are back to square one - another conflict with Georgia.


NATO EXPANSION – DON’T EXPECT THE RUSSIANS TO AGREE
John Marone

18.06.2008

If NATO can bring Ukrainians rule of law and a decent living standard, it would already have justified its expansion. But judging by the way other Western reforms have been perverted in Ukraine, one couldn’t be blamed for having serious doubts. Probably with more candidness, Mr. Yushchenko pointed out that Ukraine can join any international organization that it likes.


WESTERN INTEGRATION – THE GREAT ORANGE HOPE
John Marone

05.06.2008

Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko and his one-time ally Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko have increasingly traded blows over the country’s budget, privatization, energy policy and, most recently, the Kyiv mayoral elections; however, when it comes to foreign policy, the two politicians who rose to power during Ukraine’s 2004 Orange Revolution show unusual and possibly even unintended solidarity.


UKRAINE'S NATO BID - IT'S NOT OVER YET
John Marone

07.04.2008

NATO leaders arrived for their summit in Bucharest last week in an atmosphere of uncertainty bordering on mistrust. Outgoing US president George Bush continued to push for the inclusion of Ukraine and Georgia into the alliance, while European heavyweights Germany and France voiced the opposition of older member states to further eastern expansion.


NATO SUPPORTERS GO ON THE OFFENSIVE
John Marone

21.01.2008

The issue of whether Ukraine should join NATO has returned to the public agenda, sparking off heated debates between supporters and opponents of the country’s bid. In the past, such polemics have usually meant proponents of Euro-Atlantic unity coming under attack by pro-Russian factions in the run up to an important election or a NATO-sponsored military exercise on home soil.


UKRAINE’S NATO DILEMMA
John Marone

16.07.2007

To be or not to be a member of NATO – that is the question for Ukrainians, who still aren’t in a position to decide the issue. Public opinion polls conducted in the country continue to show that most Ukrainians are against joining the Western military alliance. But advocates of NATO membership  insist that Ukrainians have not been given an accurate picture of what the alliance is about.


UKRAINE SHOULD NOT JOIN NATO
Jules Evans

07.11.2005

I was at the first US-Ukrainian conference in Boston last week. The first speaker, a former US National Security Council wonk named John Tedstrom, was particularly excited about Ukraine’s move to join NATO, which at the moment looks more realizable than its other ambition to join the EU. NATO accession, said Tedstrom, would help anchor Ukraine in a trans-Atlantic-focused foreign policy.



Author’s opinion on other topics

THE U.S. IS SHORT OF MONEY TO PLACE ANTI-MISSILE DEFENSE SYSTEM IN EASTERN EUROPE

24 September 2009

Barack Obama sees the situation in proper perspective. Unlike his predecessor George Bush, Barack Obama understands that the U.S. cannot solve all the global and regional problems independently.


RUSSIA-UKRAINE GAS CONFLICT AND THE EU’S STAND

14 January 2009

Russia-Ukraine gas conflict has led to reinforcement of the EU's activities in the post-Soviet area.


"WEST SHOULD ADMIT THAT RUSSIA HAS ITS OWN INTERESTS"

22 September 2008

The USA, where the presidential election campaign goes full swing, tries to take the toughest possible line with Russia. In many respects that is why some American government officials seek to support Georgian leader Mikheil Saakashvili.


RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN CONFLICT. EUROPE SUPPORTS THE U.S. POSITION

20 August 2008

Yesterday I could say that in Europe there were differences in relation to Russia’s actions in South Ossetia. Some countries blamed Georgia for the conflict, others blamed Russia. But at present there is a different tendency.


RUSSIAN PRIME MINISTER VLADIMIR PUTIN VISITS FRANCE

30 May 2008

Vladimir Putin’s visit to France is quite unique. In a week new Russia’s President Dmitry Medvedev is to arrive in France and Germany. It looks like Prime Minister Putin overshadows President Medvedev. During his visit to Paris Vladimir Putin shows the world leaders that he is in charge of the Russian foreign policy.


CIS INFORMAL SUMMIT

26 February 2008

All the CIS leaders arrived in Moscow on Friday to participate in the informal summit. This indicates their respect for Russia’s President Vladimir Putin who steps down in spring. Unlike ex-President Boris Yeltsin, Putin did his best to create the working atmosphere within the CIS. Much was done in the sphere of the economic integration.


FRENCH-RUSSIAN RELATIONS

12 October 2007

The economic interests prompt Nicolas Sarkozy to get to the Russian market. The French big business and, first and foremost, state corporations urge the President to do so.   

GEORGE BUSH AND VLADIMIR PUTIN IN KENNEBUNKPORT: RESULTS OF THE INFORMAL MEETING

03 July 2007

The meeting could have made the breakthrough if the USA had backed the idea of creation of the joint anti-missile defense in Azerbaijan. However, few people reckoned on that. Vladimir Putin made public this idea at the G8 Summit, and George Bush neither rejected nor supported it.


G8 SUMMIT IN HEILEGENDAMM

07 June 2007

At the Summit the world leaders create the stabilizing atmosphere showing that they have many interests in common. So, neither George Bush nor Vladimir Putin are expected to make strongly-worded statements.


RESULTS OF THE RUSSIA – EU SUMMIT

22 May 2007

As to the influence of the new French President upon the EU policy towards Russia, from now on Russia will have to consider the EU's opinion.


DO RUSSIA AND THE WEST FACE A NEW COLD WAR?

19 March 2007

I believe that there will be no Cold War between Russia and the West. Though there are many misunderstandings connected with the Russian President Vladimir Putin’s speech in Munich.


ON ANGELA MERKEL’S VISIT TO RUSSIA

19 January 2007

The German EU presidency will most likely give a chance to stabilize Russia-EU relations and establish strategic partnership.


MOSCOW-BERLIN-PARIS: PROSPECTS OF THE ENERGY ALLIANCE

25 September 2006

Russian President’s proposal to direct the gas stream from Shtokman deposit to Europe’s market should be viewed in a broader context.   


A VISIT OF ANGELA MERKEL TO RUSSIA

26 April 2006

The fact that the city of Tomsk is visited by one of the most important and largest German delegations emphasizes significance for Germany to develop the relations with Russia.


A VISIT OF FEDERAL CHANCELLOR OF GERMANY ANGELA MERKEL TO RUSSIA

04 January 2006

I believe that Angela Merkel’s visit to Russia is of great importance. She will put her own mark on the relationship between Russia and Germany. On the one hand, Germany’s policy towards Russia is going to be changed. Under Merkel, Germany seeks to be the closest friend of the USA, as Great Britain is. Unlike France, Germany is not going to act as Russia’s main advocate in the EU.

 events
 news
 opinion
 expert forum
 digest
 hot topics
 analysis
 databases
 about us
 the Eurasia Heritage Foundation projects
 links
 our authors
Eurasia Heritage Foundation