|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN CONFLICT. EUROPE SUPPORTS THE U.S. POSITION
ALEKSANDR RAHR,
Director of Russia, Ukraine/CIS programs, German Council on Foreign Policy, Coordinator of the EU-Russia Forum, Germany
Yesterday I could say that in Europe there were differences in relation to Russia’s actions in South Ossetia. Some countries blamed Georgia for the conflict, others blamed Russia. For example, the French and German settlement plan was strongly supported. They pinned serious hopes on it.
But at present there is a different tendency. The USA has changed the Europeans’ opinion, and the EU and NATO may revise their relations with Russia seriously. Russia may be even excluded from G-8, the Russia-NATO Council may be disbanded, etc.
The Europeans have no political will and desire to be involved in the conflict in the Caucasus. The European politicians will not go beyond the talking stage. That means that the EU is most likely to let NATO play the key role in the settlement of the armed conflict, which would be a serious mistake.
Russia is short of good diplomatic tools to bring its position to Europe. Many Russian diplomats were educated in the Soviet system. They have revised their approaches, and changed a lot. But even now the West would understand only few of them. Europe will not accept the position “if somebody does not understand us, it is not our problems”.
There are quite a few Russians in Europe who have the European mentality. But there are no tools to make Russia’s position clear for the European policy-makers through those Russians.
August 14, 2008
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Other materials on this topic
Hot topics
Digest
07.04.2008
|
RFE/RL: U.S./RUSSIA: FRIENDLY WORDS, BUT BUSH AND PUTIN FAIL TO RESOLVE DISPUTES
|
Setting aside growing tension on a number of issues, Putin and Bush appeared eager to end their presidential relationship on a high note.
|
03.04.2008
|
RFE/RL: NATO WELCOMES CROATIA, ALBANIA, BUT ASKS UKRAINE, GEORGIA, MACEDONIA TO WAIT
|
Speaking today at NATO's summit in Bucharest, Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer said the alliance wants to welcome Ukraine and Georgia as members someday.
|
25.12.2007
|
THE GEORGIAN TIMES: WITH OR WITHOUT RUSSIA?
|
The foreign policy priorities of the presidential candidates. Most put Euro-Atlantic and NATO integration front and center, but good relations with Russia is, for some, another major consideration.
|
12.10.2007
|
RFE/RL: EU MAKING ITS VOICE HEARD IN MOSCOW'S BACKYARD
|
What Europe does want to do is to support democratic reforms in former Soviet states like Georgia and Ukraine, and push for change in autocracies like Belarus.
|
09.10.2007
|
RFE/RL: FRANCE'S SARKOZY TAKES CRITICAL STAND ON FIRST TRIP TO MOSCOW
|
Far from offering the warm embrace shown Moscow by his predecessor, Jacques Chirac, the 52-year-old Sarkozy has been nothing short of blunt in expressing his views on Russia.
|
17.05.2007
|
RFE/RL: EU. PROSPECTS FOR RUSSIAN SUMMIT LOOK BLEAK
|
There are growing signs that the May 18 talks in Samara may not result in much progress. As has become the norm, there are no plans to issue a joint statement underlining areas of agreement, and the EU appears most concerned with minimizing potential damage.
|
08.05.2007
|
RFE/RL: FRANCE. SARKOZY WIN LEAVES FOREIGN POLICY UNCLEAR
|
Much was made during the French election that proves Nicolas Sarkozy to be an outspoken admirer of the United States. But most of his foreign policy intentions remain largely unknown.
|
16.04.2007
|
THE MOSCOW NEWS. MISSILE DEFENSE: SUBSTANTIVE CONSULTATIONS OR EMPTY TALK
|
The U.S. plans to deploy missile defense elements near Russia's borders was the subject of a recent telephone conversation between Presidents Vladimir Putin and George Bush.
|
|
Expert forum
THE EU CRISIS PARADOX
|
ALEXANDER BORISENKO
|
08.08.2008
|
The rejection of the Treaty of Lisbon on June 12, 2008 by the Irish electorate made a lot of noise in the world. Ireland was given a number of different epithets, from “Europe's gravedigger” to “the last bastion of democracy”. |
DETERIORATION OF THE RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS
|
ALEXANDER RONDELI
|
23.07.2008
|
I do not think there is a relation between the UN Security Council meeting where the Russian fighter jets’ violations of the Georgian airspace were discussed and the withdrawal of the Russian railroad troops from Abkhazia.
|
“RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS CAN BECOME MUCH BETTER”
|
EROSI KITSMARISHVILI
|
21.05.2008
|
Currently, there are several negative points in the Russian-Georgian relations. The first one is Georgia’s bid for the NATO membership, the second one is Tbilisi’s conflict with the breakaway territories – Abkhazia and South Ossetia. There are also the problems of the bilateral relations.
|
DOES NATO ENLARGEMENT POSE A THREAT TO RUSSIA?
|
KONSTANTIN ZATULIN, ALEXANDER KONOVALOV, TATYANA PARKHALINA, OLES DONIY, LEONID KOZHARA, IVAN ZAETS, ANDREW KUCHINS
|
07.04.2008
|
"Why do the Central and Eastern European countries seek to join NATO? For many of them it is a way to join the EU. Many countries took this as institutionalization of independence from Moscow. For many countries it was a way to return to Europe," Tatyana Parkhalina.
|
NATO, THE CIS AND RUSSIA AFTER BUCHAREST
|
STEPHEN BLANK
|
02.04.2008
|
In advance of NATO’s Bucharest summit Russia has decided to employ the traditional Soviet tactics of intimidation and blackmail to block NATO’s enlargement.
|
NATO-RUSSIA BREAK: A SIGNIFICANT POSSIBILITY
|
GEORGETA POURCHOT
|
01.04.2008
|
The Bucharest NATO summit offers a significant possibility that NATO’s and Russia’s positions on a variety of issues will further diverge, marking the beginning of the end of this uneven relationship.
|
SOUTH OSSETIA STATUS: LOOKING FOR A NEW APPROACH
|
GHIA NODIA
|
26.07.2007
|
On July 24 Tbilisi hosted the first meeting of the State Committee on the status of South Ossetia. The Committee is intended to work out an approach to resolving the argument about South Ossetia’s status that would be acceptable both to Georgia and South Ossetia.
|
SHADE OF KOSOVO OVER GEORGIA
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
13.06.2007
|
The pending recognition of independence of the Serbian province Kosovo by the United Nations and attempts by Russia to apply the “Kosovo precedent” to the conflict zones in the post-Soviet space might reverberate negatively for Georgia.
|
RUSSIA-NATO: PROSPECTS OF COOPERATION
|
VYACHESLAV IGRUNOV
|
01.06.2007
|
One of the major issues directly concerning the relations between Russia and NATO is the Alliance’s enlargement and accession of new members, the former Soviet republics (Ukraine and Georgia) to the Alliance.
|
MODERN RUSSO-AMERICAN RELATIONS
|
SERGEI ROGOV
|
07.05.2007
|
Unfortunately, I have to state that the strategic partnership between Moscow and Washington has failed. The partnership exists in words only. And there are several reasons for that.
|
GEORGIA – NATO: PROSPECTS FOR COOPERATION
|
MERAB PACHULIA
|
09.03.2007
|
Ambitions of the Georgian authorities to develop cooperation with NATO are largely supported by the population. There is a consensus on the benefits that the country could receive after acquiring membership of the Alliance, though contradictions remain.
|
GEORGIA’S WAY TO NATO STREAMLINED
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
19.02.2007
|
Members of the “National Forum” and some other opposition parties fear that Georgia may join NATO without Abkhazia and South Ossetia, thus losing those territories for good.
|
RUSSIA-EU SUMMIT
|
VIKTOR MIRONENKO
|
23.11.2006
|
In the run-up to the Russia-EU Summit, one can say with certainty only that the Summit will start preparing the new Agreement on Partnership and Cooperation.
|
EU-RUSSIA SUMMIT
|
VICTOR MIRONENKO
|
25.05.2006
|
The relations between Russia and EU today are cooler than ever, they are in the state of limbo “between war and peace”.
|
A VISIT OF ANGELA MERKEL TO RUSSIA
|
ALEKSANDR RAHR
|
26.04.2006
|
The fact that the city of Tomsk is visited by one of the most important and largest German delegations emphasizes significance for Germany to develop the relations with Russia.
|
RUSSIA - EU SUMMIT
|
VASILY LIKHACHYOV
|
04.10.2005
|
The main component in the agenda of the upcoming Russia-EU Summit would be the discussion of the four Road Maps.
|
ABKHAZIA: NEW EASTERN POLICY
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
29.07.2005
|
The Georgian minister on conflict settlement, Giorgi Khaindrava, called the recent meeting between the leaders of Abkhazia and South Ossetia a "statehood game." While Georgian officials continue to describe political developments in the breakaway republics in this way, Abkhazia is taking a number of very important political steps that may give its cause a boost.
|
RUSSIA - EU RELATIONS
|
FYODOR LUKYANOV
|
04.07.2005
|
The Russian government’s refusal to invite the Presidents of Poland and Lithuania to celebrate a 750-year anniversary of Kaliningrad can be interpreted as Russia’s desire to show the new Europe that it has more important and influential friends in the EU. The leaders of Germany and France Gerhard Schroeder and Jacques Chirac were invited to the celebrations of Kaliningrad's 750th anniversary.
|
RUSSIA-EU RELATIONS
|
NIKOLAI KAVESHNIKOV
|
02.06.2005
|
The future of the European Constitution is becoming increasingly gloomy after the referendum in the Netherlands. The Dutch refused to support the dreams and ambitions of politicians and chances for a repeat voting are minimal.
|
CAUCASUS IN THE GEOPOLITICAL CONTEXT
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
28.05.2005
|
The Russian military presence in Georgia has become the key issue of the Caucasian Big Game in the last few months. Discussions of the timeframe and speed of their withdrawal from Georgia overshadowed the problems of Abkhazia and South Ossetia.
|
|
Opinion
ENOUGH GRAND-STANDING BY THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT
|
Jules Evans |
27.08.2008
|
The typical criticism of the UK’s Foreign Office is the one eloquently expressed in John Le Carre’s The Constant Gardener - that they are pitiless practitioners of real-politik who care more about stability than idealism, and who only really work to protect the interests of British corporations, rather than British values. But on Russia, the Foreign Office seems to have erred on the other side.
|
TRUE COLORS - UKRAINE'S REACTION TO CONFLICT IN SOUTH OSSETIA
|
John Marone |
18.08.2008
|
By sending troops into Georgia earlier this month, the Kremlin has shown its willingness to use force to check the advance of the West into what it considers Russia's zone of influence. The pretext for the invasion, Georgia's military clampdown on its separatist region of South Ossetia, is irrelevant.
|
BAD HABITS ARE CONTAGIOUS
|
Boris Kagarlitsky |
14.08.2008
|
Georgia has resolutely condemned Russia’s actions in Chechnya. Russia has severely criticized NATO actions towards Serbia. Later on the Georgian authorities tried to do the same thing in South Ossetia as the Russian authorities had done in Chechnya. Moscow decided to treat Georgia in the same way as NATO had treated Serbia.
|
VICIOUS CIRCLE
|
Boris Kagarlitsky |
17.07.2008
|
The Russian foreign policy boringly runs around in circles: the row with Estonia on the historic past, the squabbles between Moscow and Kyiv over the Crimea and Russia’s Black Sea Fleet, the confrontation with Georgia because of its breakaway republics etc. After having made a full circle we are back to square one - another conflict with Georgia.
|
GEORGIA COULD BE OBSTREPEROUS OVER RUSSIA’S WTO BID
|
Jules Evans |
20.11.2006
|
The Georgian government has apparently been offering olive branches to the Russian government over the last two weeks, with the demotion of hawkish defence minister Irakli Okruashvili to the ministry of economy (he’s since resigned).
|
|
Author’s opinion on other topics
THE U.S. IS SHORT OF MONEY TO PLACE ANTI-MISSILE DEFENSE SYSTEM IN EASTERN EUROPE
|
24 September 2009
|
Barack Obama sees the situation in proper perspective. Unlike his predecessor George Bush, Barack Obama understands that the U.S. cannot solve all the global and regional problems independently.
|
"WEST SHOULD ADMIT THAT RUSSIA HAS ITS OWN INTERESTS"
|
22 September 2008
|
The USA, where the presidential election campaign goes full swing, tries to take the toughest possible line with Russia. In many respects that is why some American government officials seek to support Georgian leader Mikheil Saakashvili.
|
RUSSIAN PRIME MINISTER VLADIMIR PUTIN VISITS FRANCE
|
30 May 2008
|
Vladimir Putin’s visit to France is quite unique. In a week new Russia’s President Dmitry Medvedev is to arrive in France and Germany. It looks like Prime Minister Putin overshadows President Medvedev. During his visit to Paris Vladimir Putin shows the world leaders that he is in charge of the Russian foreign policy.
|
CIS INFORMAL SUMMIT
|
26 February 2008
|
All the CIS leaders arrived in Moscow on Friday to participate in the informal summit. This indicates their respect for Russia’s President Vladimir Putin who steps down in spring. Unlike ex-President Boris Yeltsin, Putin did his best to create the working atmosphere within the CIS. Much was done in the sphere of the economic integration.
|
FRENCH-RUSSIAN RELATIONS
|
12 October 2007
|
The economic interests prompt Nicolas Sarkozy to get to the Russian market. The French big business and, first and foremost, state corporations urge the President to do so.
|
GEORGE BUSH AND VLADIMIR PUTIN IN KENNEBUNKPORT: RESULTS OF THE INFORMAL MEETING
|
03 July 2007
|
The meeting could have made the breakthrough if the USA had backed the idea of creation of the joint anti-missile defense in Azerbaijan. However, few people reckoned on that. Vladimir Putin made public this idea at the G8 Summit, and George Bush neither rejected nor supported it.
|
G8 SUMMIT IN HEILEGENDAMM
|
07 June 2007
|
At the Summit the world leaders create the stabilizing atmosphere showing that they have many interests in common. So, neither George Bush nor Vladimir Putin are expected to make strongly-worded statements.
|
RESULTS OF THE RUSSIA – EU SUMMIT
|
22 May 2007
|
As to the influence of the new French President upon the EU policy towards Russia, from now on Russia will have to consider the EU's opinion.
|
DO RUSSIA AND THE WEST FACE A NEW COLD WAR?
|
19 March 2007
|
I believe that there will be no Cold War between Russia and the West. Though there are many misunderstandings connected with the Russian President Vladimir Putin’s speech in Munich.
|
ON ANGELA MERKEL’S VISIT TO RUSSIA
|
19 January 2007
|
The German EU presidency will most likely give a chance to stabilize Russia-EU relations and establish strategic partnership.
|
A VISIT OF ANGELA MERKEL TO RUSSIA
|
26 April 2006
|
The fact that the city of Tomsk is visited by one of the most important and largest German delegations emphasizes significance for Germany to develop the relations with Russia.
|
A VISIT OF FEDERAL CHANCELLOR OF GERMANY ANGELA MERKEL TO RUSSIA
|
04 January 2006
|
I believe that Angela Merkel’s visit to Russia is of great importance. She will put her own mark on the relationship between Russia and Germany. On the one hand, Germany’s policy towards Russia is going to be changed. Under Merkel, Germany seeks to be the closest friend of the USA, as Great Britain is. Unlike France, Germany is not going to act as Russia’s main advocate in the EU.
|
|
|
|
|