|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SUMMING UP THE UN SECURITY COUNCIL MEETING ON GEORGIA
SERGEI MARKEDONOV,
Head of the International Relations Department of the Institute for Policy and Military Analysis, Moscow
I believe that the withdrawal of the Russian railroad troops from Abkhazia and the UN Security Council meeting, which was held on July 21 at Georgia’s request, cannot be directly linked to each other. Here we should rely on facts. The facts show that neither the UN Security Council officials nor their representatives said that it was necessary to withdraw the railroad troops.
As for the UN Security Council meeting, nothing new has happened. Georgia expressed its position again and was supported by the USA. Unlike the USA, the EU countries are unwilling to comply with Georgia’s requests and support it in solving the issues of Abkhazia and South Ossetia.
It is logical that Georgia appeals to the international organizations for support. It has no resources to use force, although, probably it would like to do that. That’s why Georgia wants to be the winner in other areas including the diplomatic one and to get the most advantageous negotiations format.
It is significant that Georgia’s State Minister for Reintegration Temur Iakobashvili stated that Georgia tried to reject the existing formats of the conflict settlement because of their ineffectiveness. This is only Georgia’s point of view. But the opinions of all the conflict and the negotiating process participants must be taken into consideration too.
Russia used the UN Security Council meeting as a new rostrum for expressing its views. But the Russian diplomats should highlight in their speeches the humanitarian situation in South Ossetia.
It is strange that at the UN Security Council meeting nothing was said about the atrocities in South Ossetia, for example, that on July 4 when Tskhinvali was under fire, a seventeen-year-old boy had been killed.
So, the issue of the nonuse of force must be given priority. First and foremost, the Russian diplomats should discuss this problem rather than the issue of the unrecognized territories status or the choice of intermediaries in the conflict settlement.
July 25, 2008
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Other materials on this topic
Hot topics
Digest
25.12.2007
|
THE GEORGIAN TIMES: WITH OR WITHOUT RUSSIA?
|
The foreign policy priorities of the presidential candidates. Most put Euro-Atlantic and NATO integration front and center, but good relations with Russia is, for some, another major consideration.
|
|
Expert forum
DETERIORATION OF THE RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS
|
ALEXANDER RONDELI
|
23.07.2008
|
I do not think there is a relation between the UN Security Council meeting where the Russian fighter jets’ violations of the Georgian airspace were discussed and the withdrawal of the Russian railroad troops from Abkhazia.
|
BURJANADZE RETURNS?!
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
11.07.2008
|
Ex-chairwoman of the Georgian Parliament Nino Burjanadze who had scandalously quitted President Mikheil Saakashvili’s team right before the May 21, 2008 parliamentary elections, returned to politics the very way that was most expected from her cautious and pragmatic mind.
|
INFORMAL CIS SUMMIT IN ST.PETERSBURG
|
VLADIMIR ZHARIKHIN
|
09.06.2008
|
The main result to be drawn from the informal CIS summit is that under the new Russian President Dmitry Medvedev Russia's policy in the post-Soviet space will not change drastically.
|
GEORGIA AFTER THE PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS
|
ARCHIL GEGESHIDZE
|
29.05.2008
|
There are several reasons behind the victory of the “United National Movement” in Georgia's parliamentary elections, which took place on May 21. One of them is that the ruling party has drawn the right conclusions from the January presidential election.
|
RESULTS OF PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS IN GEORGIA
|
DAVID BERDZENISHVILI
|
23.05.2008
|
There was a lot of electoral fraud in the parliamentary elections that took place in Georgia on May 21. Such elections do not favor the rapprochement between Georgia and NATO. At the NATO summit in Bucharest it was decided that all the Alliance members would observe the parliamentary elections in Georgia carefully.
|
SITUATION IN ABKHAZIA
|
SERGEI BAGAPSH
|
22.05.2008
|
What will Abkhazia do, if Georgia joins NATO? Abkhazia will do nothing. Let Georgia join NATO even tomorrow. We do not care about that.
|
“RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS CAN BECOME MUCH BETTER”
|
EROSI KITSMARISHVILI
|
21.05.2008
|
Currently, there are several negative points in the Russian-Georgian relations. The first one is Georgia’s bid for the NATO membership, the second one is Tbilisi’s conflict with the breakaway territories – Abkhazia and South Ossetia. There are also the problems of the bilateral relations.
|
THE RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
25.04.2008
|
Almost all significant political forces in Georgia, including the ruling party, say that there are sufficient reasons for making the compromises with Russia that would not infringe upon Georgia’s national interests.
|
PRESIDENT OF GEORGIA OFFERS ABKHAZIA BROAD FEDERALISM
|
ALEXANDER KRYLOV, ALEKSEY MALASHENKO, ANATOLY OTYRBA, SERGEI MARKEDONOV, SHALVA PICHKHADZE, ZURAB ABASHIDZE, IVLIAN KHAINDRAVA
|
14.04.2008
|
"For the first time the President of Georgia has put forward such far-reaching proposals," Alexander Krylov.
|
VISIT OF THE U.S. PRESIDENT GEORGE BUSH TO UKRAINE
|
DMITRY VYDRIN, YEVHEN KOPATKO
|
01.04.2008
|
"The purpose of the visit is to enlist the Ukrainian diaspora’s support in the U.S. presidential election. The diaspora is quite numerous and has always backed the Republicans. But recently the Republicans have become less popular with the American Ukrainians," Dmitry Vydrin.
|
WILL THE POST-SOVIET BREAKAWAY REGIONS BE RECOGNIZED?
|
DMITRY MEDOEV, GURAM GUMBA, SERGEI ARUTYUNOV, SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
19.03.2008
|
"If to look at a map, one can realize that in the event of the conflict in Abkhazia the Georgian party is doomed to defeat, as has happened before. This is why Abkhazia has a very good chance of becoming independent," Sergei Arutyunov.
|
RUSSIA AND THE CAUCASUS KNOT: PROSPECTS FOR A SOVEREIGNTY PARADE
|
DMIRTY MEDOEV, VLADIMIR KHOMERIKI, MIKHAIL ALEKSANDROV
|
17.03.2008
|
"After the recognition of Kosovo, South Ossetia’s position remains unchanged. When asked about our attitude to that precedent we have always answered that it is South Ossetia that can be a de jure precedent for Kosovo, not vice versa," Dmitry Medoev.
|
THE RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS AND THE SITUATION WITH SOUTH OSSETIA AND ABKHAZIA
|
KONSTANTIN GABASHVILI
|
06.03.2008
|
Georgia’s wishing to change the format of the Mixed Verification Committee on Settlement of the Georgian-Ossetic conflict and the consideration by the State Duma of the Russian Federation of the situation with South Ossetia and Abkhazia during the March 13 parliament hearings are different things.
|
WILL THE VECTOR OF RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS CHANGE?
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
24.01.2008
|
It is unlikely that after the election President Mikheil Saakashvili has changed his position on Georgian-Russian relations. For the time being, the statements about his wish to normalize those relations cannot be taken seriously.
|
SOUTH OSSETIA STATUS: LOOKING FOR A NEW APPROACH
|
GHIA NODIA
|
26.07.2007
|
On July 24 Tbilisi hosted the first meeting of the State Committee on the status of South Ossetia. The Committee is intended to work out an approach to resolving the argument about South Ossetia’s status that would be acceptable both to Georgia and South Ossetia.
|
THE “SANAKOEV” OPERATION
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
03.07.2007
|
The Georgian authorities did their utmost to convince the Europeans in Brussels that Dmitry Sanakoev was not Tbilisi’s puppet, but a representative of the Ossetian population in Georgia including the breakaway region.
|
SOUTH OSSETIA’S CLONED SEPARATISM
|
OLEG FESENKO, VITALY KULIK
|
13.06.2007
|
Early in May the Tbilisi officials voiced that “it is necessary to carry on the political dialogue with the authorities of the Tskhinvali region”. But Mikheil Saakashvili’s government decided to negotiate with the “alternative President” of South Ossetia Dmitry Sanakoev, who is close to the Georgian government.
|
SHADE OF KOSOVO OVER GEORGIA
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
13.06.2007
|
The pending recognition of independence of the Serbian province Kosovo by the United Nations and attempts by Russia to apply the “Kosovo precedent” to the conflict zones in the post-Soviet space might reverberate negatively for Georgia.
|
GEORGIA’S WAY TO NATO STREAMLINED
|
ZAAL ANJAPARIDZE
|
19.02.2007
|
Members of the “National Forum” and some other opposition parties fear that Georgia may join NATO without Abkhazia and South Ossetia, thus losing those territories for good.
|
ABKHAZIA: NEW EASTERN POLICY
|
SERGEI MARKEDONOV
|
29.07.2005
|
The Georgian minister on conflict settlement, Giorgi Khaindrava, called the recent meeting between the leaders of Abkhazia and South Ossetia a "statehood game." While Georgian officials continue to describe political developments in the breakaway republics in this way, Abkhazia is taking a number of very important political steps that may give its cause a boost.
|
RUSSIA AND THE CAUCASUS REGION
|
VYACHESLAV IGRUNOV
|
17.06.2005
|
The agreements on the closure of Russian bases in Georgia, which were reached after dramatic negotiations and moves, have cast a fresh light on Russia's role and future in the Caucasus.
|
|
Opinion
VICIOUS CIRCLE
|
Boris Kagarlitsky |
17.07.2008
|
The Russian foreign policy boringly runs around in circles: the row with Estonia on the historic past, the squabbles between Moscow and Kyiv over the Crimea and Russia’s Black Sea Fleet, the confrontation with Georgia because of its breakaway republics etc. After having made a full circle we are back to square one - another conflict with Georgia.
|
GEORGIA COULD BE OBSTREPEROUS OVER RUSSIA’S WTO BID
|
Jules Evans |
20.11.2006
|
The Georgian government has apparently been offering olive branches to the Russian government over the last two weeks, with the demotion of hawkish defence minister Irakli Okruashvili to the ministry of economy (he’s since resigned).
|
|
Author’s opinion on other topics
THERE ARE NO PRO-RUSSIAN POLITICIANS IN GEORGIA
|
19 May 2009
|
What does the current situation in Georgia mean for Russia? On the one hand, the confrontation between the government and the opposition is Georgia’s domestic affair. Whoever wins the struggle, no one would take a pro-Russian position.
|
FIFTH ANNIVERSARY OF THE ROSE REVOLUTION
|
25 November 2008
|
The main reason why the fifth anniversary of the Rose Revolution is not celebrated with a great pomp is that the Georgians are bitterly disappointed with the results of the revolution. In fact, nobody was going to carry out democratic reforms, although the ‘revolutionaries’ had set themselves this goal.
|
WILL THE VECTOR OF RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS CHANGE?
|
24 January 2008
|
It is unlikely that after the election President Mikheil Saakashvili has changed his position on Georgian-Russian relations. For the time being, the statements about his wish to normalize those relations cannot be taken seriously.
|
GOVERNMENT RESHUFFLES IN GEORGIA
|
20 November 2007
|
There is no alternative to the incumbent president Mikheil Saakashvili in the forthcoming presidential polls in Georgia. Like it or not, he stands to win the forthcoming elections. The opposition cannot compete with Saakashvili.
|
RUSSIAN-GEORGIAN RELATIONS
|
01 March 2006
|
I would like to analyze the deadlock crisis in the Russian-Georgian relations and to suggest a way out of this crisis.
|
ABKHAZIA: NEW EASTERN POLICY
|
29 July 2005
|
The Georgian minister on conflict settlement, Giorgi Khaindrava, called the recent meeting between the leaders of Abkhazia and South Ossetia a "statehood game." While Georgian officials continue to describe political developments in the breakaway republics in this way, Abkhazia is taking a number of very important political steps that may give its cause a boost.
|
|
|
RUSSIA AND THE CAUCASUS REGION
|
28 June 2005
|
Nagorno-Karabakh was the first ethnic conflict that shook the foundations of the political power "vertical" of the Soviet Union and became the detonator that exploded it. It enriched our active political vocabulary with such terms as "ethnic cleansing" and "cleansing of the territory." As a result of the Armenian-Azeri conflict over Karabakh, about 500,000 Armenians had to leave Azerbaijan, and about 200,000 Azerbaijanis had to leave Armenia. Both states (particularly Armenia) have essentially become homogenous mono-ethnic entities. During the armed clashes over Karabakh, Azerbaijan lost 13% of its original territory.
|
RUSSIAN - GEORGIAN RELATIONS
|
19 June 2005
|
Russia's relations with Georgia are one of the most cute and problematic aspects of foreign policy in the Caucasus. Previously "fraternal," i.e. former Soviet republic, Georgia has become one of Moscow's most intractable partners in the former Soviet space.
|
CAUCASUS IN THE GEOPOLITICAL CONTEXT
|
28 May 2005
|
The Russian military presence in Georgia has become the key issue of the Caucasian Big Game in the last few months. Discussions of the timeframe and speed of their withdrawal from Georgia overshadowed the problems of Abkhazia and South Ossetia.
|
CENTRAL ASIA IN THE GEOPOLITICAL CONTEXT
|
28 May 2005
|
Many people in Russia see America's presence in the post-Soviet (Eurasian) area as virtually an attempt to end Russia's national sovereignty. Alexander Dugin, a prominent theoretician of Russian traditionalism, recently said the United States was trying to penetrate the "canonical territory" of Russian diplomacy. However, the military-political presence of the world's No.1 superpower in some ex-Soviet republics might become an important stabilizing factor.
|
|
|
|
|